>Jaynes was a professor at Princeton University, so he must've built up enough credibility to get this appointment
Well, Pauling got two Nobel prizes, but still had crackpot theories about Vitamin C
Well, Pauling got two Nobel prizes, but still had crackpot theories about Vitamin C
Well, is it "simply because they don't fit with the dominant paradigm" or rather because they have been discredited time and again?
And the cliche about "dominant paradigm" ignores the actual reasons the theory is rejected. Quantum Theory shows that a theory will be accepted even if fundamentally breaks with the dominant paradigm - as long as it can be confirmed by evidence. So that is not really the issue.