1. Median obviously is less suspect to a small number of very
popular comments which probably describes many users pretty
well. It's the "betting value" for a game where loss is
linear with error.
2. I'm not sure whether median would be higher or lower for
most. Poisson distribution suggests higher medians, but
many probably have a bunch of 1-karma comments to weight
the origin.
3. A HUGE psychological difference is that median would be
discreteness. Instead of seeming to be a smooth value
related (probably naively) to community engagement and
improvement it'll look more like a set of clubs. 0-medkarma
could be a rabble-rouser, 3-medkarma is consistently
meaningful. 10-medkarma means maybe you should run for office.Psychologically, it diverts attention away from a specific number, and toward a general concept of "goodness", segregated by club. Then, rather then concentrating on getting the next karma point, users try to enter certain club, and each club has a general identity to it (with the top being those who provide thoughtful, intelligent responses, and typically only speak when they have something to say).
Creating different clubs (creating classes of users) isn't arguably bad so long as there is easy mobility between classes based on merit.
The natural question is how and whether to indicate the "class" or "club" a user is in. Make it public? Indicate it in comments? PG tried a red dot next to high-karma users some time ago, then scrapped it; maybe there's some other way to reward users based on club achieved.
Both thoughts depend on figuring out more completely what club membership means; it's something I can't flesh out well despite having a feeling it might be beneficial.
What if the average rounds everything under some threshold (say -10) up to that threshold? So your total karma can get totally trashed by one heavily-downvoted comment, but there's a limit to how badly your average gets hit.
But really, I'd guess that 99% of comments that go below -10 are clearly intentionally trolling, so it's probably not an issue.