I wonder how something like this is even remotely debatable, its not like we invented free speech just the other day and now are working out the finer details of whats ok to say in front of law enforcement, let alone the fact that it seems like they have wide discretion to interpret the law at that particular moment according to how they are feeling emotionally.

On the other hand, what if you refuse to speak to any officer, even one that has no probable cause but would like to know if its gonna rain today and asks if you could check your phone and tell him and you decide to ignore or walk away from said officer? Does that establish enough probable cause (granted the officer feels slighted) to order you to speak or perform an action or present ID? Then, if they decide you are not complying with orders and put cuffs on you, how ironic would it be that you now have the right to remain silent once under arrest but never before?