Do they not understand it? Did they get paid to pass it? Do they hate freedom? Do they actually think it's a good law? Would they like to have lived in the USSR so they can experience the peak non-freedom experience? Are they masochists?
Do they not understand it? Did they get paid to pass it? Do they hate freedom? Do they actually think it's a good law? Would they like to have lived in the USSR so they can experience the peak non-freedom experience? Are they masochists?
Plus, a law like this only really sets the stage for future actions. If it turns out those type of actions are unnecessary or have detrimental effects, the capability can be restrained in the future! And it is true that the egregious totalitarian scenarios we're thinking of won't be done immediately. The frog will just slowly boil over time as the invasive behavior is normalized and gradually used for more and more routine policing.
It takes a very principled stance to assert that the unenumerable harm such laws do to the future outweighs the immediate threat of the day. Which is why totalitarian laws such at this gain more ground after violent media spectacles.
Meanwhile, if they vote for it, they annoy the few people paying attention or who have strong feelings about it. Low risk in the short term.
I only took an interest in politics since the selling of Telstra and then the NBN stuff, and man, I wish I'd been more aware earlier in my life.
I haven't worked out how I'm going to introduce my kids to "the decisions that will shape their futures" yet, without turning them into suicidal nihilists bereft of hope for the future of the species / planet - but that's kinda the point.
The biggest attackers to Australian democracy is Liberal/Labor's actions. Are they trying to turn Australia's democracy into USA's?
I'm sure whoever is proposing the law knows precisely what they're doing: making Apple and co. choose between money or values.
The USGov want's this and would be offering some incentive. The government then use that as a selling point or threat of missed opportunity to keep MPs in line - not that you'll ever get someone crossing the floor.
I assume the idea is to either "share" the data to a five-eyes partner or let them collect it and use their jurisdiction to compel it's decryption (including by US firms).
There's also a lot of politics and point scoring going on, and a trade deal is always good coming into the next election.
What I'm saying here is that "corporate lobbying" is a bugaboo for many people. There are plenty of bad ideas that stem from sources other than corporate lobbying.
They in turn talk to USGov and work on what they get and the selling points.
From the politicing it was the old "you're going to put people's safety at risk" if we don't do this message. So, no idea what AU gets out of it unless there a deal that makes some other issue go away for the Gov like taking some of our refugees, etc.
Corps get no say unless they need a sweetener to keep giving politicians money or favourable media via various industry bodies and groups.