Surely the correct counter-move for Google would have been to say "We will respect the DNT flag in all browsers except IE".
Is it really? Let me try:
You're going down the street while eating some cookies, and suddenly you meet a friend.
Opt-in: A friend sees your cookies, and asks, "Can I have one?"
Opt-out: A friend starts taking and eating your cookies, and says, "Tell me if you want me to stop."