Speaking as somebody who owns a classic car, drives carefully to baby said classic and often rides shotgun... I gotta say: most drivers are pretty decent. The people I hear complain about how awful everybody else is... they're either old and drive dangerously slow, or they're super entitled and drive aggressively. Since we're on HN, I'm gonna guess you're of the latter camp. Do the world a favor: take Uber and don't write AI.
While it is amusing, doesn't HN encourage people to be civil?
I don't get paid by-the-hour to drive; I get paid to arrive on-time. So commuting in my opinion (like IT in MBAs' opinion) is purely a (time-)cost center. And from that POV the average driver is indeed absolutely terrible. Ever since I started working in the software industry, I don't think I've ever taken the wheel of my car and driven it somewhere, without getting angry at another driver along the way.
Granted, different drivers can be terrible in different ways.
Some of them do stupid mutually-harmful BS like pulling out right front of me with minimal margin and no intent to travel at even half the speed-limit.
Others think that because they have an 8-cylinder engine and a traditional automatic transmission, that they should rule the streets - which they can and do, but that doesn't make me any less angry at them when they e.g. pass me at a 20mph relative-speed on the same side into which I was signalling to change because I was behind a schoolbus.
And no, talking about the avarage human being's ability to operate a specific machine over the course of their life is not painting any individual with a broad brush.
Also, an individual can be a good driver. People in general may not be. That's not a contradiction or an insult. Heck even a "good" driver can drive badly.
Ironically though, Uber is then taking that money and putting it into their own AI so they can get rid of one of their bigger expenses; human drivers.
No, I simply expect others to follow the same laws that I'm bound to and that I follow. The Golden Rule. And a lot of drivers on the road simply do not do that.
> humans are remarkably adaptive and can convey intention through body language -- even through a "puppet body" like a motor vehicle. Humans can, by and large, adapt to "terrible" drivers -- swerving to avoid the aggro asshats
I agree with you here, but this doesn't really help demonstrate that humans are not, on average, poor drivers. That some of us can compensate for the shortcomings of others is great, but the fact that we not only compensate for the shortcomings, but that we're able to suss it out of such fine data — seems only to be evidence that we have a need for it, because collectively our driving is bad. Perhaps you can teach an AI to read the "body language" of a car, but I imagine that such a thing would be remarkably subtle and considerably difficult.
(On the whole, I don't think it really matters what the skill level of humans are. The AI must perform better, or else what's the point? Ideally, we should be able to prove that it's better — so as to sway public opinion, and I suspect that will be the hard part.)
Quite the opposite, on average humans are 99.99999% reliable when driving cars.
Math: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12012166
Computers on the other hand are nowhere near that reliable.
1. The cost of screwing up is very high.
2. There are important events in the real world environment that are not very recognizable or predictable.
3. Humans accept a level of danger from other human drivers that they absolutely will not accept from robocars.
Also I think the actual hardware is not good enough yet. LIDAR is great but humans can see really far in really good detail and can work out what is happening even in really bad conditions (rain, looking into the sun, etc).
Non-motorway driving is just too varied. I still think the first real application of autonomous vehicles will be driverless lorries that drive between depots that are connected by motorways. It's way way easier because the environment is so restricted, there's a clear commercial need, and people would be a lot more comfortable about the safety aspect - who hasn't seen a lorry drift into the hard shoulder? Plus lorries are super expensive so it wouldn't increase the cost too much, and they're huge so there is plenty of space for hardware.
If, instead, we have a set of local sensors setup that identified the new "safe" path, an automated car could easily go through this new section. As marked, however, it would be very dangerous to rely on an automated driver.
The challenging cases are probably things like children playing on the side of the road, pedestrians, bicyclists, construction workers, cops standing in the street, people working in manholes, and so on. Relatively small, easily obscured, unpredictable, hard for computers to figure out how they are moving, and very high cost to hit.