YC not just represent SIGNIFICANT NUMBER they represent some(!) of the BEST startups. Thats why they can access vendors, bloggers etc. YC is a credible brand that would be hard to earn for the new group.
Whats wrong with BrainTree? I my mind possible 10% discount from vendors is too small treat that doesnt solve any significant problems that founder meets to organize a few new group for it.
Just my 2c
Pardon my Eng
YC does represent some of great startups, but I am not sure I would say "BEST". That's kinda difficult to quantify.
They can access vendors, bloggers, etc. because of the quality of their portfolio.
Imagine, for a second, there is an association/group with the likes of Patio11's BCC & Appointment Reminder, 37 Signals, Derek Sivers latest project, and any of the other solid startups lurking on these HN threads. I don't know, if any of the above would want to be a part of an association/group like this - until they see what it's made of and can do - but a group that represents 20 - 50 (eventually, not overnight) of companies like that could be enough to attract blogger interests and get better terms from vendors.
It's not just about the discount from vendors. Think of it as a way to leverage the collective for the benefit of all the members. Kinda like AARP or AAA - or some other union (except it's not a union, per se).
I don't know if this has ever been done, or if it can even be done. But I am simply exploring the possibility and gauging the interest.
Besides, remember that YC was not always the large, powerful brand it is today. It started with just a handful of startups just a few years ago. So I don't imagine we will be able to achieve the same thing, but if there is some way we can foster camaraderie, and do good for the entire group and add value, there might be something here.
The bigger question is to what extent people that might use such a service have their needs already satisfied by meetup groups, OSS communities (especially well-marketed ones like Rails), this website even?