weev was put in jail because he wittingly conspired with others to steal AT&T customer data via a vulnerability on their website. In his correspondence with journalists and IRC logs surrounding the event he went out of his way to make abundantly clear that he was fully aware that this access was unauthorized.
At the time, weev himself described his actions as "theft".
You could sum a SQL injection attack down to "accessed a public url structure in an unintended manner", but that'd just be terribly dishonest.
I agree there's a continuum from hitting URLs with predictable structures to blatant hostility like SQL injections, but the problem with the CFAA is that it doesn't draw a clear line on that continuum.
I'm not sure why the third circuit would be relevant at all in this conversation to be honest.
I don't see where the "stuff about freedom" comes in here.
Smurfing and boosting are kind of similar (boosting does twice as much damage: account goes up, then it falls down). Smurfing sometimes causes damage for fun, boosting causes damage for money.
"Damage for fun" is relative. Maybe it is a part of the game.
But "damage for money" means that it's an open system now, and some people have jobs to damage the matchmaking.
B) you make an almost impossible comparison to get to the resolution of
The freedom ideals in the US are part of a social contract that sometimes is reflected by judges to nullify laws that undermine that social contract, but the contract itself is part of a meme - like the pledge of allegiance - made for children in the 1940s to boost morale and national identity in a time where it made a real difference.
The nuances of the 55+ sovereign institutions in the US can never be simplified that easily.