Because they’re probably paying Marriot for the privilege of being listed as a provider for monitoring services. Once the free tier runs out they’ll try to milk the consumers for an ongoing protection charge.
> - Why is that not a service provided by a bank, as a part of having a credit card?
Separation of concerns. A bank or card issuer cares more about covering their own liability for fraud on a particular card. They don’t care if a new one gets issued in your name somewhere else or if a line of credit gets opened.
> - Why do individuals have to pay some random third parties to protect themselves from some fraudster defrauding some bank via data obtained from some company (even if, in publicized breach cases, this gets covered by breached company)?
That’s not strictly true. Freezing your credit across all the major credit agencies is free. They likely don’t want you to know or do that as it also limits junk mail for credit cards.
> - (Somewhat related) how is it that your "credit score" isn't just a number on your bank dashboard, but you have to pay third parties to discover it? It can't be that all of this is just a legalized racket, can it? Because if feels like it is.
It is a racket with a private sector origin that effectively got standardized over the years. There’s a number of private organizations that provide “credit scores” with FICO being the most prominent.
Starting a few years ago most financial providers provide free access to your current score or some “fako” equivalent.