While viewing these in the lens of a corporate handout, it is definitely a practice that deserves a close look, pretending that entire state governmental bodies in the US are acting outside of their own best interest (both fiscally and politically) deserves a conversation
> A normal way for governments to raise revenue in the United States is with property taxes. If you build a gigantic new office tower somewhere, then you are going to owe a lot of property taxes to the local government.
> So if you’re smart and have good lobbyists, you’ll say, “Hey, we were thinking of building a huge office tower in your city, but your taxes are so high. Maybe instead of paying the 8 percent property tax rate that’s on the books, we could pay 2 percent instead for the first 20 years.”
> The city may well agree to this proposal because 2 percent of a giant office tower is still a lot more than 8 percent of a parking lot. What’s more, bringing your office tower to town is going to generate a lot of sales tax and income tax revenue while probably helping to bolster property values across the board. So while reporters are going to write, accurately, that your company got millions of dollars in tax breaks in order to build your office tower, the city still ends up with more tax revenue than it would have had if you hadn’t come to town.
> So you can’t really say things like, “Instead of handing out millions in subsidies to Jeff Bezos, we should invest in the subway.” The subway doesn’t need a tax break; the subway needs actual money. And the tax breaks don’t represent money in hand that could be spent.
> What we want is a healthy form of competition where companies try to locate in cities that provide a high quality of public services relative to their tax revenue, so that cities have an incentive to try to govern themselves well. The current dynamic not only allocates too much surplus to rich companies, it undermines that healthy form of competition. Amazon doesn’t need to care whether New York City has cost-effective government or not; it just opts out of paying the costs.
> But the very fact that mayors are inclined to hand out these subsidies should teach them a lesson about tax policy.
(The lesson being that, if giving these tax breaks out is beneficial, maybe you should have been taxing something else in the first place.)
How does corporate bargaining power work? Suppose two states and one corporation operating in both states. The corporation says to each state, "I'm reducing the employee count in your state unless you reduce my taxes." The threat is credible and is in neither state's interest. Unless the two states talk to each other and both agree to not reduce the tax rate, a social guarantee is in jeopardy. A union or cooperation of the states disallows the corporation the ability to punish and reward individual states, reducing the means to manipulate each individual state's tax rate to the corporations liking.
Why do you think BT has a big engineering presence in all 4 parts of the UK? or why the BBC was forced to move to Manchester
When states unite and cooperate they are exercising their right to self assemble or self association. Often individual states exercise this right after chronically being picked apart by a powerful adversary and find they don't want to leave behind the benefits the union provides.
I don't know enough about specifics in the UK to answer your questions. Union members typically vote on the direction of the union or leadership positions and so these members are responsible for their decisions or leadership.
The companies were squeezing all of the benefits from having the company be there out of the city.
It took decades for some cities to wise up and realize that having a sports franchise wasn’t worth all of the incentives they give the leagues.
Also, per the same article, the stadium's nominal capacity for soccer is 41K, so average attendance of 53k is pretty damn good.
Additional tax income needs to cover the additional demand for services, otherwise it's a net loss for the community's standard of living.