Don't Touch Anything
unintendedconsequenc.es
unintendedconsequenc.es
This is a terrible position to take. The unintended bad consequences described, in this post and in the other posts on the site, are all reasonably predictable to anyone knowledgeable who's making a serious effort. And sometimes projects don't have unintended bad consequences, or the unintended bad consequences are worth it, or they would be manageable if only someone bothered to predict them.
For example introducing the cane toad to control cane beetle, the larva which it was assumed the toad would dig up and eat despite the toad not having that kind of habit.
It is possible that the desire to appear to be doing something overpowered the motivation to actually do something. It is also possible that the people involved simply didn’t realise how incompetent they were to make that decision.
I think that's worthy of study. That's what this project is about. Glad you liked it!
I think you might be bringing that interpretation to the site. At least, reading the linked article, I don't find it there explicitly. Maybe you are taking the "Don't Touch Anything" title too literally? The author speaks positively of the attempts to reintroduce beavers to Scotland, and seems cautiously optimistic about the attempts to eradicate the accidentally introduced brown tree snake from Guam.
Looking at some of the other articles on the site, I see a message akin to your correction. For example, instead of saying "don't do anything", this article is about how "bounty" programs should be run differently to make them more effective: https://unintendedconsequenc.es/the-cobra-effect-redesigned/. His recommendations sound about the same as your criticisms.
No, it's actually: therefore you should exercise extreme caution before making any irrevocable change.
Mother earth is checked into no revision control system, and every change is comitted live on the production system. Caution is advised in such circumstances.
AD 2018: Same except substitute some other term for “gods”.
It is manipulating nature that we learn about nature and uncover new things. Ultimately, if it had not been for farming, we would never had landed a human on the moon. Humans are the first earth species who is not limited to earth. Within our lifetimes we could have humans successfully living on another planet. Let us respect the intricacies of nature, but not get intimidated into inaction and passivity. Our human ability to adapt earth to our needs on a scale far above any other species is a feature not a bug.
Seems like it bothers only the farmers there so far...
That just depends on the time scale. Everyone is fine with dingoes ("Australia's native dogs") despite them just being dogs that have been wild here for a few thousand years. If pigs had been introduced in 500BC we'd be campaigning to save them instead of trying to eradicate them.