Why the NYT and Bureaucrats Don't Tell You the Cost of Action on Climate Change
fee.org
fee.org
- The author compares projections of climate change’s GDP cost in the US to mitigations’ GDP cost worldwide. But climate change would hit poorer and more low-lying countries harder, so the worldwide cost would probably be a higher percentage. If you want to focus on the US, on the other hand, then the cost of mitigations on the US economy alone would likely be different; my guess is that it would be lower, because we’re a wealthy country with a cleaner starting point than global average, but I could be completely wrong.
- The estimate is of “direct damage to U.S. economy”. What counts as direct versus indirect?
- Comparing economic figures ignores externalities such as increased deaths, refugees, and environmental destruction as considered a harm in itself.
- The author compares GDP to consumption when they are two different measures (no idea if this matters).
- Even if the average cost of mitigations versus cost of not mitigating are comparable, the variability is probably much greater in the latter case, due to the hugely wide-ranging impacts of climate change. Thus there are risks of much higher costs.
- In particular, the author doesn’t attempt to do proper calculations with the probability distributions involved but just ‘eyeballs’ them, so it’s hard to say how valid their comparison is.
- This: https://andthentheresphysics.wordpress.com/tag/hsiang-et-al/
For the record, I don’t care about the author’s opinion of the New York Times or the legitimacy of citing a worst-case figure, which they spend so much time complaining about. I’m only interested in their own cost/benefit calculation.
These principles include: individual liberty, free-market economics, entrepreneurship, private property, high moral character, and limited government."
This site is propaganda. Flagging this article.
Sure, it's Reason-esque, but seems silly to flag it because you don't like their opinion.