QM is really weird. One of its strangest properties is that although it contains classical mechanics as a limiting case, QM also required classical mechanics for its very formulation, see page 3 here [1]
When most people encounter QM for the first time, they want to come up with some "intuitive sounding" principles from which they can derive everything else. That's natural. Most people just give up at that and work on other things, other people take it really really far. So far no one has been able to do it, but who knows right.
In the article we can find this passage:
> A major research goal in quantum foundations, since at least the early 2000s, has been to “derive” the formalism of QM purely from “intuitive-sounding, information-theoretic” postulates
The entire approach of deriving QM from first principles without reference to classical mechanics may never work, not to mention that concept of "intuitive sounding" is highly subjective. Therefore, considering that there is no such set of axioms known at this time and the whole approach could be wrong, I find it objectionable to use this argument as a basis for explaining why amplitudes have to be complex.
[1] http://power1.pc.uec.ac.jp/~toru/notes/LandauLifshitz-Quantu...