I've had profs in college who were brilliant but couldn't teach, and profs who could teach but weren't brilliant (didn't produce much original research).
I wouldn't say the former group "didn't know their material well", but they didn't build up the material systematically. Pedagogy was neglected. Explaining things is an art that not every has the inclination to master (but they should).
But what would be the best is if you are allowed to skip ahead lectures, etc at your own pace. The competitive incentive here would have been a big extra motivator.
Of course, you cant blame stagnating scientific discovery, stagnating prosperity, and soaring academic costs on the Academic Complex. Teachers, especially, are beyond reproach.
I once had a professor who was new to teaching. It was a very painful experience and the entire CS class spent every lecture murmuring among themselves how terrible the lecture was. I gave him the benefit of the doubt and waited to 2 weeks to see if the lectures would improve. They didn't. At the end of one lecture I went and spoke to him and told him directly he was by far the worst teacher I had encountered at University and that as students we expected higher quality instruction.
From the next week on he was a good lecturer. It was a total transformation. I was seriously impressed. I guess he just never really thought about the pedagogical side of things before but to get such a rude wake up call really jolted him into action and he actually had a pretty good capacity to teach after that.
---
So what if—just another fancy idea of mine—what if Chomsky cannot find anything in my work that goes "beyond the level of something you can explain in five minutes to a twelve-year-old because" because, when he deals with continental thought, it is his mind which functions as the mind of a twelve-year-old, the mind which is unable to distinguish serious philosophical reflection from empty posturing and playing with empty words?
--Slavoj Žižek
https://www.versobooks.com/blogs/1365-some-bewildered-clarif...