I don't thing the problem really is about genetically engineering babies. I mean, we are already creating superhumans that are immune to some diseases with vaccines, genetic engineering is just a step further.
The real problem is that it is essentially unauthorized experiments on human subjects. Just like with drugs, there is a process ensuring the risks are minimized. And it look like they skipped all that.
Gene editing also has specific challenges:
- They are babies, they can't give consent themselves.
- They are (presumably) healthy to begin with. It is not a case of "with that experimental treatment, you may die, but without it, you definitely will".
- The treatment may also affect the offspring in unexpected ways.