The burden of proof should be on copyright holders to explain why the state furthers the public good by requiring the courts (and police, customs, etc.) to enforce these laws.
Legally in the United States, the power to establish copyright is in the constitution: "To promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries."
This makes indefinite copyright unconstitutional.
Heh, someone collecting money like this was the story of "About a Boy" with Hugh Grant (2002).
So Shakespeare wouldn't be used in schools, that would be great!
Share and share alike, otherwise it's pulling the ladder up, rather selfish, and a theft from all of us.
Copyright was never intended to be infinite. Every work is derivative. When we don't return works to the public domain, culture gets stale, owned by big players.
Rambo 13, 14, 15...
Rip, mix, burn has lowered the bar for creation. When we do that, and expand the pool of works to draw from, we empower people to add to culture outside the big players and whatever boardroom vision they may have.
The argument is robustness of culture, not boardroom culture.
Lots of creators coming up now. Low bar to entry. New, relevant works is what they need to take their place in society.
Some will anyway.
Who knows what may come? That's the point. That MADE Disney, BTW.
And Disney will be just fine. It's the little guy somewhere who has a vision that won't be, unless we allow the same process to play out again.
Copyright is censorship.
In Germany's analogue to the US-American copyright law (Urheberrecht), there exists no fair use doctrine.
EDIT: And even if we ignore this: a little less censorship is still a censorship.
I just stated a logical fact.
Understanding the interference rules of ZFC does not enable you to prove the Riemann hypothesis.
Understanding the standard model does not enable you to build a transmutation engine.
Understanding that copyright is censorship does not enable you to come up with a visionary plan what the best political steps are to handle this truth.
---
But I personally think that it would at least be a small step into the right direction if people would internalize that free speech and copyright are contradictory to each other.
I'm not sure whether this would be a great victory for the cause of free speech or nail in the coffin for copyright reduction.