Star Control: Origins removed from Steam after DMCA takedown notice
pcgamer.com
pcgamer.com
The fact that they're litigating this leads me to think Stardock's actions are really egregious.
Edit: after reading https://www.stardock.com/games/starcontrol/article/487690/qa... it seems Stardock only sued in response to take down notices.
Second Edit: after reading https://www.dogarandkazon.com/ I have no idea who sued who first. Both accounts don't seem to agree.
Third Edit: Watch the video in cdumler's comment it gives a very good summary from the courts.
The creators sold the rights for Star Control's trade mark, marketing and distribution rights on the condition that if the game fails to generate $1,000 in revenue then all rights revert to them. The distributing company eventually stopped selling the game. The creators presumed the rights reverted to them, but never got a declaratory judgement to legally cover that they did. The defunct rights were eventually sold through companies until it wound up with Atari, who sold the trade mark rights to Stardock. Stardock believes that the contract for the copywrite is still in effect; thus, they own the franchise.
Stardock wanted to make a game and began doing so. It's he said/she said at this point: Creators says they were in discussions with Stardock who wanted to by rights to the copywrite to make a game, but ultimately the creators said, "No, we want to make a sequel." Stardock says they told the creators they have the rights to make the game and wanted their blessings/input. There appears to be evidence that Stardock's version of events have changed over time and misrepresents events.
Whatever the case, Stardock decided to go ahead with the idea that the most the creators could own is the original characters, artwork and music. So, they made a game with the core idea but with alternate versions of the characters, art and music. The DMCA takedown was issued because it appears that Stardock then decided to use some original characters in the game, to which the original creators claim copywrite.
The most recent court ruling was less than stellar for Stardock, who used very poor legal arguments: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ieb1ajwwUFo
> Stardock wanted to make a game and began doing so. It's he said/she said at this point
The filing in the Leonard French video indicates that the court has access to correspondence between Wardell and Reiche/Ford from this period, in which Wardell explicitly acknowledges Reiche/Ford's claims to the SC1/2 IP and says that he accepts those claims as valid and would not incorporate such IP into his new game without a license from them. (Which Reiche/Ford refused to grant.)
Much later on, Stardock released DLC content packs for Star Control: Origins that incorporated some of those very IP elements Wardell acknowledged Reiche/Ford's rights to into that game. Example:
- Star Control: Origins Arilou Content Pack: https://steamdb.info/app/899550/
- The Arilou alien race from Star Control and Star Control 2: http://wiki.uqm.stack.nl/Arilou_Lalee%27lay
So if Wardell is saying now that he has never accepted Reiche and Ford's claimed rights to the SC1/2 IP, and the court has written evidence that at one point in the past he absolutely did acknowledge those rights, that would put the dispute outside the "he said/she said" zone.
This is actually really common place and appears near identical to how 20th Century Fox owns rights to Star Wars Episode 4 but Disney own the franchise and can use the same characters and develop derivative products.
• Reiche and Ford own the entire copyright on Star Control I and II, including code, story, universe, etc.
• Reiche and Ford own copyright in the characters reused in Star Control III, but Accolade owned the code and all characters/concepts new to the SC3 universe. (Accolade had to get permission from Reiche and Ford to use their characters in this game.)
• The name/trademark Star Control has always been owned by Accolade.
• Distribution rights and royalties for SC1 and SC2 were granted to Accolade for a fixed period of time, or until a fixed period went by with no sales, or until Accolade ever went bankrupt.
All this was written down in a contract between Reiche/Ford and Accolade decades ago; the original document is readable in the court filings.
All three of the termination conditions above have since occurred, so Reiche and Ford claim—correctly, in my layman’s opinion—that the distribution rights for SC1 and SC2 (except for the name) reverted to them years ago.
When Atari tried to sell SC1, SC2, and SC3 on GOG in 2011, Reiche and Ford disputed it. Both sides agreed to split revenues equally, and the game went back up on GOG (see the email chain in https://www.dogarandkazon.com/blog/2018/2/27/report-from-pla...).
But when Stardock tried the same thing on Steam in 2017, relations soured dramatically, leading to a Stardock lawsuit claiming Reiche and Ford hold no rights and were not the creators, and DMCA takedowns from Reiche and Ford.
However, it seems that while Stardock supposedly thought they bought the Star Control (lore) franchise/IP from Atari/Accolade; that's simply not the case as Atari never owned the franchise, just Star Dock 3 additions to the franchise and the trademark.
“We won't be making any changes to the existing Star Control games. And Atari doesn't actually own the copyright on Star Control 1/2 so it's not like one could make a Star Control 2 HD or what have you without a license from Paul Reiche. And even if we did have rights to SC 1/2 I wouldn't touch them without his blessing.”
[1]: https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2013/07/stardock-acquires-sta...
I simply do not know how the interpret the above quote in any other way than that Stardock was aware that at least some of the rights were retained by Paul Reiche III at the time of, or immediately following, the purchase from Atari.
I don't see how they are, though. If those emails in Stardock's description of events are genuine, it seems Brad Wardell went out of his way to accommodate and include Paul and Fred in the project as much as possible. Paul and Fred's announcement seems to have come rather unexpectedly and seems to have been timed to coincide with Stardock's release.
While I'm generally predisposed to like two indie developers trying to claim their rights back, my impression here is really that Brad and Stardock acted in good faith every step of the way, while Paul and Fred sprang some nasty surprises on him.
Though it's entirely possible that Stardock is presenting a skewed version of the history, of course.
Fred and Paul were initially sued for saying their new game, Ghosts of the Precursors, is a sequel to the game Star Control II from 1992. Which it is. And that it contains the characters from that game. Which it does. They own the copyright on both the game and the characters, and can legally release a sequel if they want; they’re only missing the name.
Maybe it would have been wiser for them to call it a sequel to “our unnamed game from 1992.” But getting that wrong shouldn’t warrant a lawsuit, especially one with such misleading claims as Stardock filed.
In light of the response Paul and Fred filed, as well as the posts they’ve made on their blog (https://www.dogarandkazon.com/), I interpret the email chains from Stardock differently from “good faith every step of the way”: rather, as Wardell earnestly wishing to create a sequel with the original (copyrighted) characters and universe, being rebuffed, and petulantly claiming not only that his partial rights (trademark + SC3 partial copyright) allow him full control over the Star Control universe (including, e.g., to incorporate Paul and Fred’s characters in DLC for SC:O as he has done) but also ludicrously claiming that they never owned any rights at all, despite contracts to the contrary. I quote from Stardock’s complaint above:
> This at least 30-year long misrepresentation and false narrative that Reiche and Ford peddled to Accolade, Atari and to fans of the Classic Star Control Games [that they are the “creators” of Star Control], has resulted in Reiche (who contracted with Accolade and was paid to develop the game despite never having rights to what he purported to license to Accolade) effectively holding hostage whatever copyrighted material that exists in Star Control II and preventing others (including the true authors) from benefiting from it.
I tried to come up with a charitable reading of that quote, and simply couldn’t. To say nothing of this other quote from another comment:
I've read up a bit more on the topic by now, and especially an Ars Technica article linked to in another comment seems to give a good impression of where things have gone wrong. Stardock seems to either honestly believe or fraudulently claim to have bought more from Atari than Paul and Fred claim Atari still owned at that point.
I do think Brad Wardell is an honest fan, but he's also the CEO of a company that may have paid too much for too little, and invested too much into their game without owning all the rights they would have liked to. He did try to unite all the rights to the game in one place, whether it was his own hands or those of Fred and Paul, but was rebuffed in both cases. And while that may have been disappointing for him, Fred and Paul don't owe him anything in that regard.
I was also not aware yet that Stardock eventually did include SC2 characters in their game after having originally promised not to, but I believe that only seriously happened in a DLC that I assume was only created after relations broke down and Stardock decided to go all in on this.
At the end of the day, though, it seems Stardock assumed or pretended they owned more than they actually did, bet too much on it, hoping for Fred and Paul's endorsement which they never got. And now they've got a garbage fire that they need to turn into a success.
More detail is that if you try to purchase Start 10 which is an unlimited licence, they will try to upsell you to their other object desktop product which is a 1 year licence without telling you that you will loose access to the original unlimited product you wanted.
They then ignore you when you reach out to them about this bait and switch.
Never deal with Star Dock.
I think Stardock thought they were in a water tight position but they were not.
I know him from way back on Usenet (probably comp.sys.ibm.pc.games.strategic or something like that) when he was working on Galactic Civilizations, and he was rather insistent that games should be DRM-free, which I really appreciated. He has some other issues on which I strongly agreed with him.
But as a CEO, he seems to have trouble with the idea that a) not everybody likes him or what he does, and b) other people have rights too, and they may conflict with what he might prefer to be true.
And once he gets on the wrong side of an issue, he tends to double down and make it a bigger problem than it needs to be. I believe there was an issue with sexual harassment that he reacted really badly to, and now this. And probably quite a bit more in between.
So uh... not really making Stardock’s case look better.
who?
(And I missed the edit window for my original post... damn.)
It seems that we are past the initial anger, because it now reads "PR and FF, the _designers on_ the classic DOS game...".
If you think the DMCA is an overreaction, just imagine that Stardock legally questions whether PR and FF are the creators of SC2. Really? That nullifies any kind of sympathy one might have had towards them.
In November of 2017, Stardock made an anniversary blog post downplaying Paul and Fred’s involvement as creators of Star Control 2. https://www.stardock.com/games/article/485810/star-control-i...
Under normal circumstances, that’s innocuous—nothing more than highlighting all the people involved in the making of a great game. But even then, Greg Johnson of Starflight fame, whom I suspect had heard some of the behind‐the‐scenes goings‐on personally from Paul and Fred at that point, gently stepped in to reaffirm Paul and Fred’s role as primary creators of both the original games and the franchise. https://forums.stardock.net/485810/star-control-ii-25th-anni...
Not even a month later, Stardock filed a lawsuit against Fred and Paul, containing such incredible allegations as this one:
> …Reiche and Ford have over the course of time and up to now have repeatedly held themselves out as the “creators” of Star Control I and Star Control II, especially in their marketing, advertising and promotion of the Ghosts of Precursors Game… However, Reiche or Ford’s advertising that they are the “Creators of Star Control” is false. As Reiche and Ford know, it was Accolade, not them that created Star Control I and Star Control II. …Any authorship that Reiche and Ford may have contributed to the Classic Star Control Games was limited, and it was instead a team of many other authors, including numerous artists, animators, musicians, designers and writers, among others, that collaborated together to develop creatives used in Star Control I and II.
>…Contrary to the common public understanding and what they have portrayed to the public, Reiche and Ford may not have created any of the artwork, animation or characters incorporated in the games, or otherwise substantially contributed to the authorship of Star Control I and Star Control II. Reiche and Ford’s advertising themselves as being the “creators” of the Classic Star Control Games is false and misleading, and has been made in an attempt to dishonestly benefit from the goodwill and reputation associated with the STAR CONTROL Mark to which they have never had rights.
All of a sudden, what might have been an innocent blog post has an alternate and much more self‐serving interpretation.
Gem of a quote from the order:
> …The harm Plaintiff complains of is indeed of its own making. Plaintiff had knowledge of Defendants’ copyright claims from the outset. Despite that knowledge, it developed potentially infringing material without resolution of the IP ownership issues, and then publicized the release of that material during the pendency of this action. It now claims that its investment in Origins and reputation are on the line. Given that Plaintiff largely created the foregoing predicament, the Court is disinclined to extricate Plaintiff from a peril of its own making.