That's just... not how markets work, at all.
That's just... not how markets work, at all.
And you made up "simultaneously", so I'm going to ignore that and say "a week or two" instead.
There are thousands of major stocks that could support this with a small price movement.
If any big crypto coin had supermajority (or even 10%) of the owners try to cash out, the money would dry up right away.
Can you point to examples of large stocks having a supermajority (let's call it 66%) of all stocks move in one business week, without a corresponding crash in price? Call it dropping by half.
If, as I suspect, this sort of movement is both extremely uncommon and unfailingly accompanied by a deep discounting, then perhaps this balance of supply (people willing to sell) and demand (people wanting to buy) is part and parcel of what makes a commodity valuable, and valuable at a certain price?
Because GP was saying that market cap should be based on a counterfactual; s/he wants it to mean something it doesn't.
Generally large amounts of stock hitting the market at once results in price depression.
>The target company's stock usually rises because the acquiring company has to pay a premium for the acquisition. The reason for the premium is that the shareholders of the target company, who need to approve the takeover, are unlikely to approve the acquisition unless the stock price is above the prevailing market price. If the takeover bid equates to a lower stock price than the current price of the target company, there's little incentive for the current owners of the target company to sell their shares to the acquiring company.
https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/203.asp
Granted, this isn't a scenario where majority of owners are "dumping" the stock on the open market, but rather a scenario where a buyer is snatching up a large share of the stock. So really it isn't about the amount of stock being transacted, but the reason for the transaction (sell pressure vs buy pressure).
From these figures I find it hard to imagine being able to sell 50% of all shares within two weeks on top of all the normal trades that will also keep occurring in that time.
I will give you that the major stocks have more liquidity and can take a bigger selloff % wise than even Bitcoin or Ethereum.
When a stock leaves the S&P 500 you can have people selling off a double digit percent of ownership, but once the process is over prices tend to be quite close to where they started. And that's despite the implication that it's a bad stock.
If someone has a plausible reason to buy or sell a huge amount of stock, that isn't related to the company itself, counterparties will show up. If you offer a stock at a 10% discount for purely personal reasons, there will be many many buyers.
And as billmalarky said, in a merger you can have all the shares changing hands with only a small price shift.