This meme about taxes needs to die.
This meme about taxes needs to die.
That is expressly not the case. The government's money is not in any sort of fiduciary relationship with anyone else. The fact that you nor anyone else didn't even notice what I was talking about just shows how pervasive this meme is.
Maybe in the sense, like in Office Space, that "it becomes ours", but not in any real way. The government is the public entity; its things are everyone's things. The fact that it (with few exceptions) acts like a private entity, with entitlement to its plunder, doesn't change anything about this.
"Taxpayer's money" is useful rhetorical shorthand to remind people that creating government money requires either increasing taxes (taking money from taxpayers), printing more money ("taxing" holders of the currency through inflation), etcetera.
We have the notion of "for the people, by the people" - that the government should act in the interests of it's citizenry ("taxpayers", if sometimes quite indirectly), that the money should be spend wisely instead of wasted - both in the moral duty sense, and sometimes in the legal duty sense as well.
Can you give an example of a legal and moral use of government funds that doesn't benefit taxpayers or citizens? The closest I can come up with is foreign aid and other outwardly focused actions, which still aim to "benefit" the local citizenry through warm and fuzzy feelings, better international relationships, better access to oil and foreign markets, etc...
Literally not the case. I like how you said I misinterpreted the words of the original post but then repeated the very meme I said needs to die. It's fake news. The tax payer owes taxes to the government. The government spends its own money, not someone else's. The shallowest reflection on the matter would reveal this meme to be a sham of pure rhetoric.
And the increase in the deficits is the increase in spending on top of that.
The size of government does not inherently need to scale linearly with the size of the economy. The cost of some services may scale with population, but that's something else entirely. For example, general productivity improvements may grow the economy at the same population level, but they imply needing fewer resources to achieve the same level of government services because the same productivity improvements should make the provision of government services more efficient too.
And not all government services even need to scale with population. If we had twice as many citizens, would that really require us to double the military budget?
"Government programs expand to consume all available funding" explains why the government budget does expand with the economy, not why it should.
The frustration is that however much we dislike Tuesday government, these are the representatives that we collectively chose.