The XS is 5 mm taller, 3 mm wider, and 0.4 mm thicker. Does that kind of difference really matter?
That's not even including the very different screen interactions on XS vs the iPhone 8, where the screen itself was significantly smaller.
[0] http://nymag.com/news/intelligencer/smartphone-thumbs-2012-9...
I previously had a Note 8 for work and have just gone back to my Galaxy S7 which, while still big, is much nicer to use - even though I thought I liked the Note while I had it.
The major difference between X/XS and 8 is the weight. And this make the whole phone felt very different.