> Do I think that letting a baby starve to death because it is basically a parasite is morally desirable: no.
I read that as kirro rejecting the idea, not endorsing it. If it's not rejecting the idea of "parasite", it definitely is a rejection of the implications of the idea. That is, kirro is not attempting to dog whistle. kirro is in fact explicitly rejecting the dog whistle implications.
> Do I think that letting a baby starve to death because it is basically a parasite is morally desirable: no.
Is very different from this sentence:
> Do I think that letting a baby starve to death is morally desirable: no.
The unessential clause in this statement is, "because it is basically a parasite."
Stating it this way allows him to affirm that he thinks starving babies are a parasite on society while also signaling that he is virtuous enough to think its death is an overall negative. What is not stated, rather implied is the but, the but that belongs between the sentence:
> Do I think that letting a baby starve to death because it is basically a parasite is morally desirable: no.
And the sentence:
> Do I find the idea of trying to deduce an entire ethical framework from first principles fascinating and the way it is done interesting: yes
Basically stating: Should starving babies die? No, but, we should consider the entire ethical framework of economics from first principles that maybe requires that these starving babies die so that people are not robbed of their liberty by the taxation that subsidizes the starving babies.
The absurdity is that you defend it by exclaiming, "Those exact words are never stated!" No they are implied, I said they are implied since the beginning. Do you need a dictionary definition of what implication is in order to understand my argument? To understand his argument? To understand exactly how diseased of a philosophy AnCap is? Because that is part of the problem with AnCap, is that it implies much but states little. The implication is that modern principled society is flawed and we should return to a feudal state where the wealthy get to piss on all the plebeians because who fucking cares about peons.
> Do I think that letting a baby starve to death because it is basically a parasite is morally desirable: no.
I read that as saying that as using their wording, not as agreeing with their viewpoint.
> Do I find the idea of trying to deduce an entire ethical framework from first principles fascinating and the way it is done interesting: yes
I read that as saying that the the attempt was interesting, in an intellectual way, not saying that we should consider the resulting ethical framework at all. I read it as rejecting the resulting ethical framework in the previous quote.
Can I prove that my reading is right and yours is wrong? No. But I do note that HN guidelines require interpreting others' words charitably.