Converting Merchant Ships to Missile Ships
usni.org
usni.org
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vertical_launching_system
In general, this is not a super new idea, but it's interesting to see it getting a bit more traction.
Here's another pair of articles on the same general topic.
https://thenavalist.com/home/2017/6/22/supporting-the-fight-...
According to the very Wikipedia article you link to, firstly she's been sold to Brazil for £80 million and so is still in service, and she also cost 2/3rds what it would have cost to make it to military standards. That doesn't sound bad? (For context the article claims her cost is the equivalent of £288 million in 2016, so roughly sold for 30% of her original price).
VSEL's bid was £139.5 million compared to Swan Hunter's £210.6 million... The Financial Times described the different philosophies adopted by the two bidders; while Swan Hunter viewed the ships as entirely military, "VSEL thought the design was basically a merchant ship with military hardware bolted on." VSEL's decision to sub-contract the build phase took advantage of lower overheads at a civilian yard as well as efficiency drives by its parent, Kværne
I don't know anything about the expected service times, etc., so I'd be interested to hear if it's turned out as bad as you made it seem?
São Paulo, the ship Brazil is replacing, a former French vessel was intended to have a total service life of 80 years!
—————————-
Reply here as I am “posting too fast” apparently
The idea that in 20 years, let alone 40 years time, we'll still rely on human piloted planes is pure stupidity.
They said that 50 years ago when the first guided missiles were coming into service. They will probably still be saying it in 50 years!
The truth is that military tech just doesn’t change that fast. The B52. The 1911 pistol - that’s the year. Warship hulls are supposed to last 50+ years and you occasionally upgrade the radar. That sort of thing.
The ship that replaced her cost £3.1 billion, over 10x the cost, even when you inflation adjust.
Seems like Ocean was a bargain to me.
Edit: The more I think of this, the more insane it is. The idea that in 20 years, let alone 40 years time, we'll still rely on human piloted planes is pure stupidity. What a colossal boondoggle we've bought, and not one, but two of them!
https://www.thinkdefence.co.uk/2012/04/the-atlantic-conveyor...
That didn't involve fitting it with any defences, so the Argentinian navy sank it.
Some RN pilots were clearly keen on the idea though:
https://www.forces.net/news/tri-service/day-royal-navy-pilot...
It has been speculated that relaxed requirements or poor implementation of modifications was responsible for the sinking of the Kursk. Relaxing ammo handling procedures to achieve higher rate of fire scores in exercises may have helped to sink the HMS Hood.
There's an analogy in here somewhere concerning computer security.
As far as survivability, I wonder if something like this could scale out fast in wartime by redistributing the containers among more ships? Maybe the containers could even be watertight, so they could be fished out of the sea and reused if the ship that was carrying them is sunk.
Presuming the VLS containers are standardized, I'd expect it would be better to have more smaller ships. If that's the case, the Navy could pick up some of the older container vessels relatively inexpensively, because they aren't as economical to operate as the Maersk Triple-E class ships.
> In heavily trafficked areas, a missile merchant without sensor masts would be hard to discern from other merchant ships at range. Electronic emissions that could be correlated to U.S. Navy assets pose risks that must be mitigated as much as possible. Automated ship reporting systems should be used judiciously.
This seems dangerous to me, it seems like it will inevitably get a regular cargo ship sunk. Especially considering this second line where they also suppose that these missile merchants could draw fire from more traditional ships because of their threat.
> Drawing enemy fire could become an important function, perhaps protecting higher value, more-densely manned combatants.
Patria's 120 mm NEMO gun http://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/6440/this-120mm-gun-bui...
Northrup Grumman's containerized AGM-88E system http://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/24111/northrop-grumman-...
IAI's LORA ballistic missile system http://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/11723/israel-just-launc...
Which basically means that unless the US has very very effective anti ship missiles systems, their entire navy strategy(and thus Nato's) is broken.
The whole point of an aircraft carrier is that it provides a dome of protection. It pushes ships capable of launching anti ship missiles out of range. This means that the rest of the navy is free to do other things.
Without that cover, the navy can't move about without being destroyed.
So you either need loads of little ships (which are much more expensive to eliminate, cheaper to produce, but have smaller weapons, or have a system to effectively intercept missiles, or the missile launcher.
Wow. For comparison[0], China has 129 ships and Russia has 79. I guess the US Navy believes in overprovisioning.
[0] https://nationalinterest.org/feature/the-five-most-powerful-...
It seems harder than a quick Google search to find good numbers (e.g. the wikipedia article seems to count inactive obsolete reserve ships in its total for the USN), it seems like China has 328 ships (on an upward trend) and the USN has 280 ships (on a downward trend) [1], but obviously it's a difficult comparison because the US has more aircraft carriers, etc.
[1] https://www.lawfareblog.com/end-us-naval-dominance-asia:
> In early 2017, the Chinese Navy had 328 ships. It now possesses nearly 350 ships and is already larger than the U.S. Navy. China is the largest ship-producing country in the world and at current production rates could soon operate 400 ships. It commissions nearly three submarines each year, and in two years will have more than 70 in its fleet. The Chinese Navy also operates growing numbers of cruisers, destroyers, frigates, and corvettes, all equipped with long-range anti-ship cruise missiles. Between 2013 and 2016, China commissioned more than 30 modern corvettes. At current rates, China could have 430 surface ships and 100 submarines within the next 15 years.
> Despite the growth of the Chinese Navy, the United States retains maritime superiority throughout East Asia. But the trend is what matters and the trend is less rosy. In early 2018, the size of the active U.S. fleet was 280 ships. Going forward, according to the Congressional Budget Office, if the Navy’s budget is the average of its budget over the prior 30 years in real dollars and it maintains its aircraft carrier and ballistic submarine construction schedules, in 12 years the active naval fleet will decline to 237 ships. In six years, the U.S. submarine fleet will decline to 48 ships, and in eleven years the number of U.S. attack submarines will decline to 41 ships.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Royal_Navy#Two-...
The long standing US policy has been to maintain enough force to fight a major conflict in both the Atlantic and Pacific at the same time. It's basically what the British Navy was designed to do, when Britannia ruled the waves and had a globe spanning empire. The Brits basically went broke doing this and mortgaged their position as world hegemon to the US to pay for WWI and WWII. So now, the US has to maintain enough force to patrol the world's navies.
(Between WWI and WWII, there was serious talk about the US and British navy duking it out over the issue of the British war debt to the US. There were even naval war plans drafted.)
Wut
Commodity hardware is massively more powerful, uses less power, and is easy to cool compared to the dedicated stuff that sits in warships. So, the thinking goes, virtualize the warship software stack and run it on off-the-shelf PCs on a merchant ship and you're now able to operate your containerized VLS missiles from a civilian vessel.
The way the quote literally reads is that software virtualization and HPC somehow solved a physical geometry problem.