Do you have any basis for that position? I think using agile principles (ie making small modifications and testing them frequently to get feedback) seems like a great way to design a complicated piece of machinery.
Do you have any basis for that position? I think using agile principles (ie making small modifications and testing them frequently to get feedback) seems like a great way to design a complicated piece of machinery.
Its a terrible, terrible way to try to design complex control systems. They must be studied and modelled and analyzed by experts in processes that have absolutely nothing to do with '2 week sprints'. =
To have a "complete" design (what does that even mean), you need perfect requirements (what does that even mean), and perfect requirement collecting has been many many times proven to be virtually impossible. You'll get an imperfect design that you'll have to work around.
In addition, you'll have waited god knows how much time for those design, while you could have been developing stuff and validate that it actually solves problems for your users.
Agile is not about making devs into assembly line workers, nobody's pretending that works (though some people are still trying to do it without realising it)
Some managers definitely think agile processes are about making developers into interchangeable widgets and maximizing their efficiency.
I agree that this is close to the opposite of the original intent.
I grok the value of learning more as you explore the solution, but there’s a huge value in planning as well as you can ahead of time. The cheapest code to change is the code you never mistakenly wrote in the first place.
There are definitely many tight feedback loops that are necessary, whether they are 2 weeks or longer. Things get tweaked all the time, especially in production. There's stuff that don't show up in testing, and there's cases that cannot be anticipated. There's definitely some control analysis to identify default tuning parameters, but the proof of the pudding is in the eating. The design tuning parameters are only initial values -- they are tweaked online while the plant runs.
There's an upfront spec but that spec only provides guidance. The real world will often surprise you. There are elements of waterfall at play, but the entire process by necessity cannot be waterfall.