my take away is this, as long as we allow states to market lotteries then the idea that private companies should be held to differing rules is wrong. either all play on a level playing field or none play. considering the misery many state lotteries are said to bring I don't see how they can stand there smug except the fact they have the courts and police power to get away with it.
A loot box is literally "Pay $1 and see what you get!", and there are percentages behind what you can get (unknown to us). It's literally no different than buying a lottery ticket, except you always get something (maybe equivalent to the value of the lottery ticket) with a chance of getting something more valuable.
Now maybe they are adjusting lootbox percentages on the back-end so too many people don't get something unique if that's how you are trying to claim it's a raffle.. but I still don't think that makes it anywhere near the definition of a raffle.
From the consumer side, insurance is the purchase of a service to cover any a future debt falling under the category of the service, ie. an unforeseeable, unintentional act of damage by or to the consumer. I have no intention of burning down my house. I pay so that if it were to happen, I am not stuck paying off a house I'll never own.
From the servicer side, it is the sale of a product whereby consumers get covered for unexpected events, yet the company gets a profit for provider the service. Assuming a correct amortization, the company gets a profit.
Insurance is gambling. The servicer is the house and always wins (unless they screw up).
That is not to say that gambling can't serve purposes other than entertainment, because it can. That doesn't make it not gambling.
Correct me if I’m wrong, but I think the difference is, no one is betting that you actually do have an unforeseen incident, so there is no bet to hedge against.
You are. When you buy insurance, you are betting that you will have an unforeseen incident and will utilize your insurance.
The fact that you are doing so to offset some financial risk doesn't change the fact that you are gambling.
I don't see why source of a risk matters here. I believe the position I am arguing against is that that motivation of hedging against risk makes gambling-like behavior not gambling.
As far as I can tell your position is:
Gambling-like behavior is not gambling if it is done to offset non-gambling related risk.
Almost, but I don't feel like this is 100% accurate, because neither involved party wants an unforeseen incident to occur - the 'win' situation, if you could call it that, is the same for both parties. I can sort of see the argument that you are betting you "won't win", but I can't see it as gambling behavior:
> I don't see why source of a risk matters here.
Gambling implies taking a risk for possible gain, no? To me, part of the difference is that the risk/chance involved (life) is not intrinsic to the transaction - it is more or less known what your returns will be, and under what conditions. Contrast this to, say, a slot machine, where the 'win' conditions are owned by the house and unbeknownst to you. There is no situation where you can know you will be paid out for any given parameters.
What about flight insurance? Is that a gamble because no one knows if you'll make your flight? Are you betting that you won't make your flight because you purchased it, or are you paying for a conditional service?
(mostly not serious) aside: if what you posit is true, is the peace of mind one gains from having insurance akin to gambling addiction?
It is? I'm pretty sure health care pricing is far more opaque than slot machine payout amounts (the opaqueness of payout rates varies by state).
You have increased the downside of not having large hospital bills. You are taking on risk, but the idea is that the small risk reduces the variance in your outcomes. See the other reply thread where I am trying to understand why reducing variance in one situation is gambling but doing it in another is not.
> if what you posit is true, is the peace of mind one gains from having insurance akin to gambling addiction?
I would say akin, but obviously not the same. In both cases you have made wager that you can be usually pretty certain has a negative expected value and the motivation for this wager is to acquire a positive/pleasant state of mind.
Paying $X is saying "I bet something will happen to me, so I need this service so I don't get screwed over." Otherwise, why buy pay anything at all?
(If you "hedge" so far you're unbalanced in the other direction, you're not actually hedging your bets any more. "Hedge funds" aren't really for hedging if you use them as a primary investment.)
In what way is it opposite? How is more betting somehow the opposite of betting?
Let's say I bet $10 that team A will beat team B with 1:10 odds (I would win 100) and then team A does really well so at half-time I bet $10 that B will beat team A with 1:2 odds (I would win 20)
I have now hedged my bets and I will at least break even. Under your understanding, that second bet is not gambling solely because of my motivation for placing it?
Let's say that instead I make a $20 bet at halftime that B will beat team A with 1:2 odds (I would win 40). Now I come out ahead no matter the outcome. Because I "over hedged" this is gambling again?
This doesn't make sense to me.
If you were doing both bets before the game started, at about the same time, then the second bet would effectively not be gambling. Not because of your motivation, exactly, but because it reduces the variance in how much money you'll have at the end of the game.
If you buy a matched pair of tickets so that you guarantee a $60 output, that's not gambling. Even if you come out ahead no matter what. (who was dumb enough to sell that to you?)
Let's say you had a bet on team A forced upon you, because of where you live or something. At that point buying a matching bet on team B is an anti-gambling behavior that removes variance from the system. It's the equivalent of insurance.
If you then keep buying team B, then you're gambling in the other direction. If you buy so much insurance that you make a profit on losing items, you're gambling. But that's not how insurance normally works. It normally pays out less then what you lose, because of deductibles and the time wasted.
> If you were doing both bets before the game started, at about the same time, then the second bet would effectively not be gambling. Not because of your motivation, exactly, but because it reduces the variance in how much money you'll have at the end of the game.
I would agree that if you could make both bets simultaneously that would not be gambling, but I don't see how that is relevant
In my example, both of the second bets reduce the variance in how much money you could gain or lose. 90,-10 after the second bet becomes 80,0 or 70,10
> Let's say you had a bet on team A forced upon you, because of where you live or something. At that point buying a matching bet on team B is an anti-gambling behavior that removes variance from the system. It's the equivalent of insurance.
Why does the source of the risk matter? You have said that gambling is based not on intention, but on effect on outcome variance. Why would the second bet in your example be any different from the second bet in mine?
Let's go with a more real world example. Let's say you have a shop near a stadium in the UK and you place bets so that you win money on outcomes that are likely to lead to vandalism or looting. My understanding of your position is that this is not gambling unless the shopkeeper miss-estimates his risk and bets so much that he gets vandalized and still comes out ahead.
In my view, the distinction between gambling and insurance is purely marketing and public relations.
I might buy a case that insurance companies don't gamble the same way that some bookies don't gamble, because they have the information they need to safely hedge their bets with certainty as they are made.
In my view, consumers generally have much less information about the risks they are hedging, that means they can't have the certainty required for buying insurance to not be gambling
If you're conditionally making the second bet based on outside factors, then you might not actually be implementing a strategy of reduced variance. (And if you were making that bet unconditionally then why did you wait until midgame?) It's tricky. I'd rather deal with simpler upfront scenarios.
> Let's go with a more real world example. Let's say you have a shop near a stadium in the UK and you place bets so that you win money on outcomes that are likely to lead to vandalism or looting. My understanding of your position is that this is not gambling unless the shopkeeper miss-estimates his risk and bets so much that he gets vandalized and still comes out ahead.
That could possibly work. If the looting is basically guaranteed, the bet acts to reduce variance. But looting tends to be pretty random, so under real life circumstances it probably wouldn't work out that way.
The laws aren't set up for such tiny corner cases, of course.
> I might buy a case that insurance companies don't gamble the same way that some bookies don't gamble, because they have the information they need to safely hedge their bets with certainty as they are made.
> In my view, consumers generally have much less information about the risks they are hedging, that means they can't have the certainty required for buying insurance to not be gambling
The information is needed to figure out a fair price for the insurance. If you don't have enough info you might overpay, but overpaying isn't gambling. If you turn a 10% risk of a $10k loss into a guaranteed $2.5k payment then you got ripped off but you didn't gamble. Your variance is still dropped to zero.
This doesn't make sense to me. What are "outside" factors and why do they matter? When you place the second bet, you have risk that you are reducing. Whether that risk has changed since you placed your first bet has no effect on whether your second bet reduces your risk or not.
> I'd rather deal with simpler upfront scenarios.
I'm sure you would, but you have failed to explain the relevance of upfront scenarios to our discussion.
> If you don't have enough info you might overpay, but overpaying isn't gambling.
You have still failed to explain WHY you think reducing risk by placing a bet that you will be injured is not gambling but placing other bets that reduce risk are.
As long as the only things involved are the "team A wins" reward and the "team B wins" reward, any bet you make that brings them closer together is not gambling.
> You have still failed to explain WHY you think reducing risk by placing a bet that you will be injured is not gambling but placing other bets that reduce risk are.
They're both not gambling. (Logistically. Legality is another issue.)
Especially when it's taken out by people who don't even own the asset being insured. For people that do, it's ideally like taking an opposing bet to the bet that you've implicitly taken by owning something that has the possibility of failure.
I guess the line is that if you're on both sides of the bet, it's not gambling.
Selling insurance is definitely gambling, but it's subject to the law of large numbers like everything else - at some point, all of the risk is ironed out by the number of things you insure. At that point, it's a government concession.
When you buy insurance you're not betting that something bad will happen to you, you're hedging your otherwise implicit bet that something bad _won't_ happen to you.
I'm betting State Farm $12 a month my apartment will burn down before I die or move out.
I remain unconvinced that insurance is anything but a legal gamble.
You and a million other people give State Farm $12 so that in the event of fire or flood affecting a subset of the pool, there's enough money collected to pay out to make claimants whole.
There are no "winners" in the insurance game, only losses. If they have to pay you, you've already lost both the premiums you've already paid as well as what people or property were damaged (gambler's fallacy at work-- your entire neighborhood is smoldering and your family is dying painfully in the burn ward, but here's your insurance check, you winner!).
In your case, even if your apartment does burn down, it's not like you walk away with a windfall (unlike gambling). The adjuster is going to see to it you end up no better off than almost-exactly how you were before the fire. You don't "win" anything, and the meager payout you get can't always replace who or what you lost in the process.
Everybody involved also loses if more peoples' apartments go up in flames than there is money in reserve-- unlike with lotteries, where the payout is distributed equally amongst the claimants.
How do you think casinos and bookies work? They spread their risk by setting lines and odds and taking a vig.
It seems so many laws are about protecting people from themselves, but then we need exceptions from them for society to work at all. Like you can't legally invest in a non-listed company if you are not an accredited investor. Maybe we should make this distinction more formal and universal. Society could have an official and transparent way a person could enter the class of people who are expected to be responsible for their actions.