I wonder if smaller sites could do the same thing or this is only working so well because they're the NYT?
I wonder if smaller sites could do the same thing or this is only working so well because they're the NYT?
Smaller sites have zero chance to strike a deal with large agencies who are serving large brands. So their only chance to increase ad revenue is to offer targeting, to improve viewability (aka put banners on top), and to hope that they will get enough of retargeting dollars.
EDIT: and once you think of it, people from Europe who are reading NYT is targeting option in itself. Most probably they are affluent, english-speaking, etc. If you are large luxury brand, this is all you need.
Just because other sites are smaller doesn't mean they can't do it or work together. Smaller sites now also don't do targeted advertising; they just hire Google or any other ad network for that. They could do the same with non-targeted ads.
About your edit: Yes, this is literally how advertising has always worked; you 'target' an entire audience, not an individual. Same for newspapers (on paper), TV, magazines, books, billboards in certain area's...
6 year experience working in ad-tech on different projects.
>Just because other sites are smaller doesn't mean they can't do it or work together.
Well, try to get a slice of Procter&Gamble or Volkswagen ad budget being a small guy and not having any targeting.
> they just hire Google or any other ad network for that. They could do the same with non-targeted ads.
This is not how it works.
If you are a small site, you set a google or any other ad network tag on your site -- right.
After that, when someone visits your site, you initiate a call to these ad networks with user cookie.
If this user is identified as known (say, male, 25-35 y.o., NY, was interested in Hi-Fi equipment) some advertiser may pay a lot to show an ad to this guy. 5$ CPM is not uncommon, and you may even get $10-20 from time to time.
If this user is totally anonymous and there are no advertisers interested in him, good luck getting even $0.5 CPM. Most probably impression will go unmonetized.
>About your edit: Yes, this is literally how advertising has always worked; you 'target' an entire audience, not an individual.
nope. in case of retargeting or even modern prospecting you do target individual, just as in example above.
If good portion of your audience is known to DMP's (Data Management Platform, basically tracking silos, google "Salesforce DMP" for example) and other ad-tech players, you will easily get x5 return on showing ads to them, as compared to anonymous users, all other things equal.
And this is how you make money being a small publisher on the internet these days.
If you run a website you are going to have to work hard to get Volkswagen to put ads on your site. Explain to them why they should care. The NYT started out small too.
Say like, combining their inventory into one source (say a supply side platform) and then offer that inventory to buy (say via an exchange).
It says so right in the part of the article that was quoted:
“The fact that we are no longer offering behavioral targeting options in Europe does not seem to be in the way of what advertisers want to do with us,” he said. “The desirability of a brand may be stronger than the targeting capabilities...
(the "he" is the NYT's SVP for global advertising)
Meanwhile, companies still have their advertising budgets; they'll just have to spend money on untargeted ads. It takes time to measure the relative effectiveness of different types of ad campaigns, so it will take a while for the market to adjust.
No, it doesn't. All it means is that Europe will become even less relevant in tech than we already are. Just because European companies can't do behavioral targeting doesn't mean companies outside of the EU can't do that and the EU has no jurisdiction over them, if they can even find out that this is going on in the first place. All it will mean that European tech companies get out-competed.
Another thing you're not considering is that the EU has 30+ languages in it. I'm sure it will be great to see advertising in languages you can't even read. That will drive home the point that only France and Germany matter even more.
>Meanwhile, companies still have their advertising budgets; they'll just have to spend money on untargeted ads.
Advertising budgets don't exist in a vacuum. Their size depends on how much money they can make based on those ads. If it costs more to advertise than it brings in as sales then you just don't advertise. If targeted ads aren't a necessity then neither are online advertisements.
Besides, as other commenters have pointed out, there is no concrete evidence that targeting individual users is any better (in terms of bringing in more sales) than targeting the combination of region, language, website topic, and on-page keywords.
If you're so worried about the sustainability of European ad agencies, maybe you should stop fearmongering and start trying to improve contextual targeting technology to such an extent that it provides even more value to your customers than behaviorally targeted alternatives. If and when GDPR-like regulations arrive in other parts of the world -- I'm pretty sure the noose is getting tighter in the U.S. as well -- your European agency will be in a perfect position to grab market share there.
Tell that to all of the ads I used to get and sometimes still get that are in Russian on sites that are in English or apps that are in English.
>your European agency will be in a perfect position to grab market share there.
They will be long dead by that point. Even if they weren't they would be in no place to grab market share, because every region is going to have their own unique rules which means that the biggest companies will profit the most.
I'm no web dev, but couldn't sites use the HTTP header `Accept-Language` to pick appropriate ads?
Perhaps it doesn't make sense for the LA Times, but I'm wondering how large the investment really is and whether or not it would start getting worth it if you look at (say) 3 or 5 year periods.
It's a market targeting and opportunity cost question. Yes, many of Apple's consumers are probably high-priced wine consumers. And yes, winemaking is a profitable business. That doesn't mean, however, that Apple serves its interests by expanding into wine.
It's promising, though, that we now have data showing psychotic targeting practices are unnecessary. Perhaps, even inefficient.
Perhaps you meant psychographic?