This is why the Occam's razor rule is important. He formulate a (weird) hypothesis, he thought 3 or 4 ways to prove that the hypothesis is false, then he failed to prove that the hypothesis is false. Then the conclusion is???
The possibilities are:
* A weird asteroid
* A disabled alien probe
* A functional alien probe
* Something more weird
All four variants have almost the same level of support now. But using the Occam's razor we should favor the first one until more evidence is discovered.