They show signs of knowing about older languages but not understanding them. For example perl has dynamic variables (this is a huge win and for me the only good thing I have to say about the whole language)... but they're default. We had already fought this out in Lisp and found out that while they're an incredible concept and should be in any language that favors mutating variables, dynamic variables should not be the default.
Python using crappy one line lambdas instead of real closures. Why? Because Guido seems to not get functional programming. Ruby copies Smalltalk but Katz says Smalltalk "goes to far". What? A lot of the problems that trip people up in Ruby aren't a problem in Smalltalk. The biggest difference between the two is that Ruby isn't image based, but Smalltalk doesn't have to be either.
For me the biggest problem with the scripting languages is that they don't have any need to exist. They usually copy features from existing languages that already did a better job. If the manpower they got had been focused on the source languages the communities could have gotten a lot farther.
>There were two main points (1) Moose is stable, (2) it is modern. "And with modern, I mean the latest research papers".
The papers he was talking about were likely the Traits papers. Traits were done first in Smalltalk and aren't needed in Lisp because CLOS has proper multiple inheritance. Moose does look ok though.