This is not a 1st amendment issue at all. Amazon, as a private corporation, has every right to sell whatever they want and conversely, not sell whatever they want. Why should Amazon help out this disgusting pedophile author? If RackSpace were hosting NAMBLA do you think they would pull it? Yes they would. Why? It's a business decision, the same reason Wal-Mart doesn't sell porn or sex toys.
Philosophy in the Boudoir was not a work of satire. And I disapproved of RackSpace pulling that preacher, too. I have lost respect for Amazon for buckling to pressure by book banners.
I find it difficult to understand how a guide encouraging paedophilia _doesn't_ break the law in some way.
Also, this is not a 1st amendment issue at all. Amazon is not obligated by any means to sell/distribute the book. The issue is entirely economical.
And I agree it's a little bit unfair to compare the two: One is a bunch of ignorant people talking about how they don't believe in mating outside their race and the other is a guide to raping children. I don't think the distinction works favor of your argument, though.
One minor benefit of this work being published, albeit an unintentional one if it is genuine, is that it will give investigators and mental health professionals a better insight into the methods and motivations of paedophilia than they might be able to obtain within the criminal justice system - that is, the author who feels free to express himself may be more informative than the one attempting to justify or explain himself to an interlocutor. It will find its most diligent readers at the FBI and among forensic psychologists.
Freedom of speech is a fundamental and inviolate right of the individual. If I wanted to hold the belief that people with the name tom are spawn of the devil and deserve 100 lashings every day, then, that is an inviolate right.
However if I publish my thoughts in a book there is no moral or legal onus for any publisher or retailer to touch it. (Of course; if a retailer makes a habit of suppressing marginal books such as those, it will get a bad name, so social pressure might force them to be less restrictive.)
I see no problem for Amazon to make either a moral or business decision not to carry this book; a book which contains unacceptable thinking to a large majority of the populace. If to carry it means negative publicity and possibly lost sales they have a duty to their shareholders to mitigate that.