FWIW I'm in a similar situation, running a moderately sized site (10 servers, ~2gbps) on leaseweb hosts, costing ~$1,500/mo - every year or so I look at cloud offerings, and see that the bandwidth alone would be something like $40,000/mo.
I also have ~10 smaller hobby projects (<100 monthly active users) which could easily fit inside the smallest cloud services, but the smallest on offer seems to be $5/mo, so $50/mo in total. For $25/mo I can get a pair of bare metal servers which host all of them with failover and a ton of capacity to spare.
Then my actual day-job is at the opposite end of the scale, where we build our own datacenters...
I am very confused by the movement towards using the cloud for everything, because I work at all sorts of scales, and can't find a cloud host who works well for any of my use-cases :S