i'm sure you don't want secure strong products.
i'm sure you don't want secure strong products.
Just as we should not demonize acts like this as something more dangerous then it is, we should not add naive feel good interpretations that makes them misunderstood heroes.
they did them to expose a weakness to the user so they could fix it.
if white hat is employed by companies, and black hat is working for malicious gain. their actions fall squarely into grey hat.
i'm not calling them saints, but it confuses me that anyone would have a issue with their actions? can you explain why they don't fit the model of grey hat?
what they do wrong?
I think that what they did crossed the boundaries of other people. It did not caused much harm, just like walking around directors office without permission and without taking away something.
I don't care about hat color games. That just serves to obfuscate issues.
Also, it was illegal and put themselves in danger for that reason. So PewDiePie along with all adults who talk from both sides of their mounth in front of audience they intentionally build from young inexperienced impulsive people can stuff themselves too. "This illegal thing is totally cool I love you, I mean don't do anything illegal, I love you for doing that ilegal thing" is mastery of double message and manipulation.
so why did the chrome cast hack include a 'how to fix this' guide?
https://www.veracode.com/blog/security-news/hackers-exploit-...
"the CastHack bug, allegedly disclosed nearly five years ago"
"A spokesperson from Google told TechCrunch, “We have received reports from users who have had an unauthorized video played on their TVs via a Chromecast device. This is not an issue with Chromecast specifically, but is rather the result of router settings that make smart devices, including Chromecast, publicly reachable.”"
google has ignored this bug as it isn't a issue with the chromecast, but the router, so using this hack to teach users to fix the router issue is a legitimate way to help users.
your analogy suck, a better one is how bug hunters work, except this bug was exposed directly to the end-user.
sorry i know colours can be confusing, don't worry about it.
point me to the laws that were broken, just because you hate a YouTuber doesn't make him a bad person.
Encouraging a crime is a crime in the UK based on the Serious Crime Act 2007
The actual hacking falls under the Computer Misuse Act 1990
If I leave my front door unlocked, return home, find that someone has gone into my house and left a note saying "Hi, your door was unlocked, you should lock it", I would not be happy. If they papered my living room with "visit this celeb's webpage" I'd be furious.
i then walk past, notice your door and the vulnerability, and then slide a note through your door explaining the vulnerability and how to fix it. you would be out of your mind to cry foul.
Felix didn't encourage a crime, come on, act your age. just because you blindly hate someone doesn't mean you can twist their words without getting called out. i'll be the first to say that he's no saint, but he's way better than the average trash that floats around on the internet.
doing charity fund raisers that are worth donating to, calling out abusive personal and companies, being the genuine face of a massive community he never asked to represent.
Computer Misuse Act 1990
(1)A person is guilty of an offence if—
-(a)he causes a computer to perform any function with intent to secure access to any program or data held in any computer [F1, or to enable any such access to be secured].
-(b)the access he intends to secure [F2, or to enable to be secured,] is unauthorised; and
-(c)he knows at the time when he causes the computer to perform the function that that is the case.
i don't believe using a google program to send out code to any device with the open ports falls under any of these, as the code didn't secure access to any program or data held, and wasn't malicious.
as he wasn't securing access, he doesn't fall foul of these laws.
as the bug had already been reported to google chrome, and they had stated it was user error, supplying the user with the means to fix it is a perfectly acceptable thing to do.
Bug hunters work with prior agreement, they don't access devices owned by third parties without it. When they do they anonymize and hisr themselves. They do indeed fear legal and go through steps to protect themselves. They complain about these processes like all the time.
2.) Dude, the hacker giraffe wrote that he had anxiety attacks due to his activities even before all this. He also wrote he could not sleep due to persistent fear that every noise is swat team knocking. He wrote that he won't touch computer and will seek job without them. I am sceptical about feasibility of the last one.
I don't know whether youtuber is good or bad person. He is definitely irresponsible when he encourages teenagers to do what giraffe did.
Giraffe did everyone good service writing that letter, so really go read it. It might be fun and games for PewDiePie, but is not for giraffe. So let's hope he won't get caught affecting him even more, that his past activities are not too bad and that he learns from experience.
3.) This is exactly what compelled me to answer. These things have very real serious consequences, but due to the way we talk about it people don't realize until is too late. Go lob for change of laws, but don't say they don't exist to kids who might believe you.
he wasn't bug hunting? he was showing users they are exposed to the internet so they could fix it!
2.) yes, i don't blame him, what was meant to be a harmless exercise in google scanning, has lead to people throwing death threats at him, and threatening law suits.
he didn't encourage any reckless actions, i see Felix as quite a rational guy.
i have read the chromecast hack, and the printer one, have you? i doubt he will, and if he does a simple defence could be made to fight for his case in court.
3.) i don't know if you are talking about me or felix? i doubt felix has a firm grasp on computer hacking law, but like i said he didn't tell them to do that, in fact he's stayed at arms length. the actions giraffe took don't fall foul of the UK law, idk about american.
i'm pretty much done with this exchange, and who ever has been down-voting my comments.
The reason they may not apply is the lop-sided extradition arrangements that the UK has with the US.
But, since this is likely a crime in both countries with a potential sentence of longer than one year in prison he faces possible extradition to the UK if anyone can be bothered with that process.
UK based hackers who attacked US computers have been (or have come close to being) extradited to the US.
It's much harder to take US based hackers attacking UK systems to the UK.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK%E2%80%93US_extradition_trea...
> The treaty has been claimed to be one-sided[3] because it allows the US to extradite UK citizens and others for offences committed against US law, even though the alleged offence may have been committed in the UK by a person living and working in the UK (see for example the NatWest Three), and there being no reciprocal right; and issues about the level of proof required being less to extradite from the UK to the US rather than vice versa.[4]
Although the US embassy does say this: https://uk.usembassy.gov/our-relationship/policy-history/the...
> Why is it so much easier to extradite someone from the UK to the U.S. than in the other direction
> It isn’t. The United States has not denied a single extradition request from the UK under the treaty; the UK has denied 10 requests from the U.S. since the treaty took effect.
> Moreover, extradition requests from the U.S. to the UK have taken as long as 13 years to work their way through the UK and European courts. For extradition requests from the UK to the U.S. the subjects are in most cases extradited within several months.
> A panel of UK extradition experts, led by well-respected retired judge Sir Scott Baker, found that the treaty is fair and balanced. Its report, issued in October 2011, provides considerable data and analysis to support the panel’s conclusions.
> The Baker panel report notes that the U.S. has a population about five times the size of the UK, but there have been fewer than twice the number of people extradited to the U.S. than to the UK. The number of U.S. requests is therefore not disproportionate.
2.) Just one note: being rational does not exclude irresponsible. Because what is in rational for Félix self-interest is not in interest of hacker giraffe nor in interest wannabe pre-teenage hackers in his audience. It might as well be rational for him to be irresponsible as his audience like it.
3.) No, he does not have form grasp of laws. Again that would be against his self interest, as he could not be funny clueless after.
I quoted him at full above. Frankly, sleezy and talking from both sides of mounth. Encouraging it while keeping plausible deniality. End result: he is safe while audience is having fun while they all think how cool consequences less it was.
4.) American law is batshit crazy with penalties, expansive and absurdly expensive even if you are actually innocent.