I took that case study in business school at Cornell. I was one of the 4 people in the class that day (there must have been 30-40 folks in the room) whose recommendation was to NOT launch. I felt so pleased when the prof revealed that the case was a disguised version of the Challenger incident.
EDIT: In response to the suggestion, below I've removed the reference to actual case study, to allow future students to enjoy it as much as I did.