https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KAFKA-2561
Not sure it's going to get done at this point. I've only recently started using kafka and found the TLS issues to be somewhat surprising. AES-NI has been around for how long now?
I speculate that this is because it's come out of the hadoop community and they haven't really had much luck implementing security features.
It looks like with Java 9 the SSL stuff in Kafka saw a drastic speed boost.
Not that I would necessarily expect the throughput to be significantly different than the native version considering the good performance of JITted Java, but was just commenting on your assumption.
I mostly work with C++, Python and Node in my day to day, so my assumptions are biased.
https://github.com/google/conscrypt
According to reports into Jetty folks, using conscript for TLS, gives 10x improvements
https://webtide.com/conscrypting-native-ssl-for-jetty/
Note, that, from what I read, conscrypt is not compiled for any of the BSDs so if you are testing there, you will have to compile conscrypt yourself