> The same reasoning applies to a car. If you have sufficient savings, you can buy yourself a new car if and when you need to. Until then, just invest the savings and reap the investment rewards, exactly like the insurance company will be doing.
But it's not the same reasoning. I can afford to buy hundreds of bags of rice every month if I need to, without stretching my budget significantly. Rice for me is pocket change, so yes insurance would make no sense.
For the vast majority of people, a car is not pocket change. Sure high income people might be able to buy another and not go bankrupt, but there's a big difference between being able to afford something, and considering the expense pocket change.