Movies Get Chess Wrong
medium.com
medium.com
Chess is a signifier. The players are smart, sometimes ruthlessly willing to sacrifice for the greater good. The opponents are doing battle often a mental proxy that foreshadows a physical battle to come. There is a slow tension to it. People get the high level concept and symbolism without understanding the nuances or in fact without understanding what a fork is or being able see it on the board let alone being able to "see it" coming.
Almost no one in a theater will see HAL's mistake at calling for mate in 2 rather than mate in 4. Sure, people find "easter eggs" and hidden messages like this after the fact and it is fun to debate but during the film this simply goes over people's heads.
Finally, this post suggests that the "average" game is about 79 moves.
https://chess.stackexchange.com/questions/2506/what-is-the-a...
Any director will be hard pressed not to take liberties regarding play and still keep the audience engaged.
But nowadays i doubt you often encounter that kind of bugs and the speed would probably be unappealing to audience.
I'd say only very casual players or nitpickers watch the movies and say...
> "Ah ha! That is against the rules/wrong/a clear mistake! I'm so smart! Silly filmmakers for not knowing such things!".
It's the same as watching a Doctor or Lawyer show. Many of these 'mistakes' are made for dramatic effect, for better storylines, or to make the situation in some way or another.
In classical time controls, chess games can easily take upwards of 4 hours, and periods of 10, 20, or 30+ minutes with NO MOVES are quite common.
It's not a game that fits easily into the mold of other mass spectator sports.
Or show involving anything HN readers would be familiar with.
“I wrote a program that reconfigures the warp drive computational algorithms to give us 50% more power.”
“In an hour? Last I looked, that whole thing was like 50K LoC. How much did you test this before you deployed it to OUR ONLY PROPULSION OUT OF KLINGON SPACE?! Someone code reviewed it, I take it?”
<Six weeks later...>
No, no one’s going to watch that (“goddamn it, Bob, quit mixing formatting commits with functional commits!”) So the director takes a few liberties, we shut up, eat our popcorn, and pretend it’s perfectly reasonable to knock that out over lunch.
This is the only one I wouldn't consider a gaffe. Plenty of casual chess players don't know this either. It flips the board layout (queens on the wrong side), and would probably feel wrong to a more experienced player, but it doesn't actually affect the game.
They'd only heard that "a king can't take a king.", but didn't know why.
I suspect that chess might have a similar situation, where someone who has played enough, even if they were never consiously aware of the convention, would get an off fealing if it were set up wrong. (Although, in the case of chess, it is truly a convention. With Go there is an objective sense in which one orientation is better than the other).
A minor prop in the background, where all the pieces are in the right starting positions, but the board was rotated wrong so the queens aren't on their colors.
It totally took me out of the comic book movie, man!
What an article like this illustrates is not that movie-makers are stupid, but that some people are so unbelievably egocentric that they believe what matters to them should matter to everyone else. That what seems obvious to them should be obvious to everyone, and if it's not then that's sufficient justification to look down one's nose at them. Never mind that they themselves are ignorant of many things others might consider important. It's a narcissistic behavior, not among movie makers but among movie critics.
I didn’t ever look at the HAL chess board in depth enough to realize HAL made a mistake/bluff but in hindsight I feel there is no way that wasn’t foreshadowing.
It's just laziness not to do hat. Many films are just collections of outsider impressions. Stanley Kubrick didn't know much about space but he had work ethics.
Unless the actual, correct mechanics of a chess game are important to the plot, then it doesn't matter and almost no one will notice, much less care. Better ROI to spend that money on hair dye for Scarlett Johannsson.
>Stanley Kubrick didn't know much about space but he had work ethics
No one would put up with Stanley Kubrick nowadays.
It matters. You don't notice it consciously but all the small details add up to the movie feeling special.
> No one would put up with Stanley Kubrick nowadays.
And that's why we end up with action movies with boring action and special effect blockbusters with mediocre but expensive CGI, and drama without good characters.
Good movies with good details can be made with little money if the people who do it have passion to do it.
I want to show my character's intelligence. I show her playing a game of chess, surprising the experienced player. The chessboard isn't important. The pieces aren't important. It is a language I share with my audience. They see "this person's smart". They barely see the chessboard.
It's like computer hacking or bombs. The light turns green from red. Our heroes have downloaded the data. The red light blinks, beeping frighteningly loudly as the timer ticks to explosion while the maintenance man walks obliviously by. The audience does not question this because the beep is not a word, the light and the ticking not a phrase, the entire scene is a concept, an entire page. It describes the fact that an explosion is imminent and it will be a surprise to the victims.
The audience has trained itself to see things like this, think concept to concept, by learning the language of the filmmaker. Some are forced out from that flow for other reasons and some just because they aren't proficient in this language that millions know. But ultimately, the shared language develops and most will learn and understand.
Either the game has an illegal board, or one player really wanted to lose and passed ~30 times while apparently still being worth discussing between the two characters.
Or, as long as the plot and characterization are good, the actual details don't matter.
Highlight, a guy playing his designated driver and getting beat on both side by a guy 50 pounds lighter.