> If approved, the restrictions would only apply to cigarettes—not e-cigarettes, cigars or chewing tobacco.
Just cigarettes. Oddly, cigars are excepted. Probably just get a lot of oddly thin and long cigar sales.
People are always going to murder, evade taxes, do illegal drugs. The fact that some people won't follow laws isn't a reason not to implement them.
I'm guessing that due to geography, Hawaii has the most chance in the US of making this work though.
Ban cigar sales and many people will get deliveries by domestic mail. That doesn't hold for cigarettes.
> Ban cigar sales and many people will get deliveries by domestic mail. That doesn't hold for cigarettes.
I bet you're right for people who currently seek out cigars (more or less). But I suspect there will be some substitution effect of cigars for cigarettes, if a bill like this is passed, and cigars can still be sold locally. I expect the effect would be smaller in magnitude if cigars could only be purchased from mainland sellers and shipped via USPS. But I am just speculating.
If so, then you're just debating implementation details which I think is less important and less interesting than the real discussion about what personal autonomy, and personal responsibility, you should have to live your life as you see fit.
I was intending it as an rhetorical question.
Agreed personal autonomy, and personal responsibility are the interesting questions, not really where the comment I was responding was leading though.