This is a false dichotomy - the options are wider than "unregulated lenders" and "non-existant lenders". Imagine saying in 1850: "Many 8 year olds work in coal mines. If you remove that option, those kids aren't any better off."
This is a false dichotomy - the options are wider than "unregulated lenders" and "non-existant lenders". Imagine saying in 1850: "Many 8 year olds work in coal mines. If you remove that option, those kids aren't any better off."
> Imagine saying in 1850: "Many 8 year olds work in coal mines. If you remove that option, those kids aren't any better off."
Why are kids working in mines if they already have better alternatives? If it wasn't their best option, why would they pick it? Yes, you're making them worse off by removing their best option.
if kids don't have a better option than working in a coal mine at 8, society needs to come up with that better option, rather than giving the kid/family the current "best".
Don’t ban the undesirable thing, figure out why people are doing the undesirable thing in the first place and address that.
Btw the children example is bad because there is an entirely separate argument about the child not being old enough to make decisions that completely muddies the point.
It used to be that kids were treated like little adults and were considered fully capable of decision making. Now it seems like a lot of people want adults to be treated like kids and protected (if you can call it that) from opportunities to make bad decisions.
For that matter, ever notice how if you wanted your kid to work the fields, that school holidays sure have mighty convenient dates ? That's not a coincidence ...
So they very much did not remove the option of having kids work in the coal mines and on the fields. Not for a LOOOONG time after the 1850s.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_labor_laws_in_the_United...
You could apply that here: the government could get into the payday lending business and enforce a maximum interest rate that way.
I disagree that it does not still matter.
For the past few centuries or so (depending on what country you're looking at) the church had the monopoly on morals and the state had the monopoly on violence. It seems to have in the last 100yr (in the US at least) the government, and to a lesser extent corporations, have replaced the church as the source of morals for a great deal of the population in Europe and North America.
Public education is a great net good but we need to be careful with it because the line between education and indoctrination is a fine one. I think that the replacement of church provided education with public education poses a slow long term risk to secular societies.
You do not want the entity that has a monopoly on violence also controlling education and with it morality. That's how you get the crusades, the USSR, etc. I'm not sure what the solution is. I don't think increased religion is it.
FWIW I am not religious.