Is anyone here able to corroborate the claim made in OP's linked comment? And does anyone know what kind of experience and oversight the researchers doing discovery in big pharma will have?
Is anyone here able to corroborate the claim made in OP's linked comment? And does anyone know what kind of experience and oversight the researchers doing discovery in big pharma will have?
Other acquaintances of mine, who are in academia, did not find these results surprising at all. In fact, one added the observation that even when the experimental results can be duplicated, the conclusions of the study are probably still not valid because alternative, more mundane explanations are often overlooked, and the peer review process these days doesn't apply sufficient scrutiny or skepticism toward this.
I don't have any anecdotes on US vs. Japanese research.
I suspect as you say it’s partly down to a lack of expertise, being thrown in at the deep end without much guidance on how to get good measurements, both practically and in terms of avoiding statistical traps like cherry-picking, allied to the pressure to find some exciting results, and journals’ lack of interest in negative results.
There are a LOT of issues with reproducbility in Bio [0] at the moment, and in US based science in general. From others in 'Big Pharma' that I know, they agree that much of bio-tech based science needs to be re-run. Others in the comments section here point out that Mainland China has a history of suspect research. That may have been true 5 years ago, but they are 'up to par' with US based researchers now. Meaning, that the Chinese have gotten more rigorous and the US has severely slipped in quality.
I mean this next statement with full honestly: I don't believe half the labs out there in the US these since about 2016 onward. From very private conversations with others, many labs are abusive, fraudulent, 'me-too' landmines, and generally lying to grant funders, donors, and potential/enrolled students in a strange game akin to 'Catch Me If You Can' style con-artistry.
Major efforts are being taken to 'fix' the system. Me-Too is a perfect example. The Nature paper that is linked is another perfect example. These efforts are very much needed and those that undertake these efforts should be applauded and emulated. That said, Max Planck's quote is the speed at which this change will occur, namely, one funeral at a time[2].
[0] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-science-cancer-idUSBRE82R... A bit old, but should get you started on more up-to-date research.
[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2018/09/what-is-f... Food Science, but it illustrates the structure that leads to fraud.
I have a friend who worked in a neurology lab a few years ago who described the PI in a similar way. I had assumed that it was not normal and told her to get the hell away from that lab asap... how sad that this kind of shortsighted idiocy is so widespread!