His real complaint as far as I've ever been able to determine is that he is a highly symbolic thinker; and because of that won't accept certain assumptions that everyone else takes as a given - usually what the Reals are. I'm very happy to accept than any length in geometry is a number by definition (hence sqrt(2), constructed by a 1-1-sqrt(2) triangle, is clearly a number corresponding to that length). He won't accept sqrt(2) as a number because it can't be represented in Hindu-Arabic notation. This isn't really a logical issue, he just won't use everyone else's definitions.
He's worth listening too because he is good at maths despite that handicap and his perspective is interesting to provoke a bit of reflection on what your assumptions are and what does infinity really mean anyway. His complaints are otherwise unlikely to catch on.