I think we have a lot to learn from how generations of infighting for control of the Roman empire led to the disintegration of civic society that allowed the Christian church to fill the power vacuum. The transition from the Principate, during which Emperors still paid lip service to the Senate, to the Dominate, where the pretense was lifted, was made possible because centuries of factionalism had destroyed the foundations that allowed checks and balances to be enforced.
Banning Facebook in the UK would cause them a significant amount of grief and likely close their London office (Facebook is the IDP for Facebook employees). Most folks are not going to go through the trouble of setting up VPNs for their phones to connect to Facebook.
China had no problem banning gmail even though it was popular there because no one had to suffer through an election for the decision. The UK doesn’t have that luxury.
I don't think this is necessarily true. The Mayor of Toronto admitted to smoking cocaine, and after that regained his former seat on the city council.
The blackmail attempt on Bezos just recently.
Trump is president, despite the mountains of dirt on it.
Bill and Hillary Clinton are still touring.
I don't think the electorate cares if you're caught doing anything adults do, and low level corruption seems to be the norm in many developed democracies.
What could any of the large data-whore companies possibly have on anyone that would utterly destroy?
Agreed, but only with the caveat that that is temporary. I think we are rapidly approaching the point that corporations will be able to sidestep the rug governments currently threaten to pull out from under them. I think that tipping point will be an interesting, if not horrifying inflection point in our history.
Furthermore, much of (at least in the US's case) the "force" you speak of is now rooted in the military-industrial complex. What happens when defense contractors find that it might be more profitable to throw their hat in with a megacorp rather than the government? It's a scary thought.
What guarantees that they will always be on the side of governments?
> That employees are becoming more loyal to their employers?
No, but the common citizen is becoming that way. Right now, are people more likely to call up their representative to try to get something done, or post something to facebook related to their political leanings?
Most people who join militaries are not career military types and most also care greatly which side they're on. True mercenaries are extremely rare.
No voters or politicians publicly come out in favour of offshore tax havens... and yet somehow, 20 years later they're still there.
The UK Prime Minister could phone up the head of any British Overseas Territory today and invite them to reform their tax reporting or else a Tomahawk will be fired at their office.
Megacorps will find it hard to resist Gunboat Diplomacy.
Let’s say that Zukerberg tells the UK government to fuck off. There would surely be consequences against Facebook’s UK assets, and maybe employees. But that’s a small part of Facebook overall, and he may decide this is worth it. Direct consequences for him will be limited. He probably couldn’t travel to the UK anymore, but would anyone else extradite him for this sort of thing? Seems unlikely. And it’s not like the UK is going to send in the SAS to kidnap him in another country.
Who advertises on Facebook and targets UK users? Companies in the UK.
Who controls the banking system through which that money flows? The UK banking system.
There are many sanctions the UK can impose short of a full ban. They can issue fines (and collect them), interfere with the Facebook cash flow, in the case of things that are crimes in both the UK and the US can formally request extradition, etc.
I think the HN crowd has been reading a bit too much cyberpunk.