Hacker News Reader

Comment by denom | Hacker News Reader

I sort of get the appeal of a '.dev' TLD, but I wish that google donated the whole thing to those who were using it informally for local development.

That would have been a good gift to all the devs out there.

View on HN

The `.test` and `.localhost` TLDs are already reserved for such purposes: https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2606

.test is OK, but as was pointed out in the HN discussion on this topic last week, .localhost is problematic in some operating systems.

localhost is reserved for a very different purpose, though .local is a reserved pseudo-TLD for a purpose encompassing much of what was suggest by GP for .dev.

.local is for multicast. Don’t use it for anything else unless you want a headache.

That's right,.local was a bad suggestions ; while the notional purpose is specifically residential, the local-use behavior that people are looking for is associated more with the reserved domain .home.arpa if .test isn't desired (.test is technically for testing DNS-related code.)

Or support multicast/mDNS and use .local.

I feel like mDNS isn't used enough in general so there are weird cross-implementation bugs in it. (Partly just because of weird overlaps between early Bonjour entities, modern mDNS stacks, and weird-in-betweeners like "UPnP".) A lot more peer-to-peer applications could bootstrap better from mDNS than currently do simply because bootstrapping from known HTTP(S) endpoints is easier and less buggy.

I've wondered at times if, say, enterprise adoption of .local and proper mDNS might be a kick in the pants to sort out mDNS and make it better for everyone.

Interesting. Because my /etc/hosts file had the following as a default:

    127.0.0.1 localhost.localdomain localhost
    ::1  localhost.localdomain localhost

I thought it was `.localdomain` that was reserved.

I really thought so too! But I can't find any reference for it.

There are more devs than just web devs. Just sayin'

Web devs aren't the only ones that need test/dummy hostnames. That being said, as mentioned in another comment, there are other TLDs already reserved for such use.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com