Why I Moved from San Francisco to Paris and joined Alan
medium.com
medium.com
I'd be much more interested in stories of people, who despite the terrors of SF (and despite not being rich/a founder) decide to stay and a build a life and family there. I feel like those stories are much less common and more interesting.
SF used the be the place you moved to when you were tired of the careerism of New York, Los Angeles, hell, maybe even Paris. In recent years, it has become the place people move from. I actually think some people might actually move from SF to NY because they're tired of the rat race and want to drop out of it, not because they want to join it.
As for Paris, well, nobody needs an excuse to want to move to Paris.
A couple of minor points:
"San Francisco never felt like home, a place to put down roots. Everyone I knew came from somewhere else, and no one was planning on staying around for long. Most people worked in tech, and they were too busy with their careers to have time to build real relationships with anyone else. As for housing, even with a good tech salary, I still felt like home prices in the area were way too high for me to ever contemplate buying a place of my own."
If you'd stayed, you wouldn't have felt this way forever. I have a friend who commented about this. He said that when he moved to SF, he wondered who was actually from SF. The longer he stayed, the higher the percentage of people he knew who had grown up in SF or nearby. Having kids and raising them here increases it even more.
I can't say you needed to try harder to stay, because housing is nuts here and it is very rational to decide not to bother, even if they can afford too stay. I have, ahem, seen people claim they are priced out of SF who turn their nose up at my south-of-280 neighborhood. But even there, you'd have trouble getting in for much under a mil. So at this point, yeah, I pretty much have total understanding for people who feel this way, though a small part of me still wonders if you didn't meet people outside of tech, including the people who grew up here, because you made a choice not to leave that bubble.
"Being an immigrant in France has also been a much more pleasant experience compared to the US." I've heard this. I mean this as a genuine question, since I don't know much about it, but... do you think this would be the case if you were an unskilled, low income immigrant, not from Canada or other prosperous country?
I have no doubt that I wouldn't be treated as kindly if I weren't skilled and educated. However they do treat me pretty well here. In the US all of the immigration officials I have to interact with seem to be getting more and more hostile. Markedly so since Trump was elected.
- To start, your salary isn't going to be what you think. When I moved to Paris in 2011 I made $100,000 in NY. My new job in Paris was 42,000 (euros) a year. So right off the bat you're probably going to be budgeting more. Plus, my wife didn't have the right to work. I believe Macron is changing that, but it doesn't mean it won't go back.
- You'll still have to pay Federal taxes if you're a US citizen. I was able to contact H&R block from Paris and sent them ALL my paystubs in order to prove that I had paid French taxes. It didn't matter, I still had to pay in a small some for federal taxes. You'll be double taxed US/FR.
- There's a 3 month trial period where the company can fire you for any reason and simply state "We don't feel you're a good fit." Sound familiar? This trial period can even be extended for up to 9 months. Once the company feels like actually hiring you, that's when you get your CDI (Contract Duration Indeterminée). Then you pretty much have to do either something illegal or absolutely nothing to get fired. Both of which take time and evidence that the company has to prepare (can take up to a year).
- There's a 3 month period to quit!! In order to balance the CDI, companies have the right to sue you for "lost productivity" if you quit without giving a 3 month notice. Don't think you're safe if you scurry back to the States. I read a blog (not sure how truthful it was), but they found her and sued her from Paris.
- If you are in your trial period it's especially hard to start a bank account, rent an apartment, etc. You're considered too much of a risk.
- If you have an accent you'll be treated like a tourist. I had a visa, carte vital, and bank account, but it takes a long, long, long time to make actual french friends. My wife and I made friends with other immigrants, mostly British, Irish, and other Americans. People say on average it takes 3-5 years to become someones friend (if they're french). Once you've made a french friend, loyalty is expected, and you'll ruin everything by being flaky.
- You have to play the 'game'. What's the 'game'? The art of conversation. So if it's difficult to get a bank account in your trial period, how did I manage to do it? I tried 3 different branches at Paribas and finally found one where the guy was willing to listen. Turns out he had traveled quite a bit himself. So what did I do with my bad attitude of being denied twice before hime? NOTHING! My reply "Oh thank you so much, you're really helping me out." Also, if you don't want a burned baguette, walk through the door of the bakery and say "Bonjour." When you're done, you say "Au revoir." If you don't you've broken protocol, this activity shall be logged, and the baker shall and will use it against you later.
Those are things to watch, here are the benefits of living in france.
- Personally, I love the language.
- Healthcare, healthcare, healthcare. Oh and did I mention healthcare. I have very conservative parents who constantly say "I don't want the government choosing which doctor I go to." This couldn't be further from the truth. I got really sick in france, and you will probably too. The germs are different and your body isn't used to them. I Went to a clinic and just like the good ol' US I thought "This doc doesn't have a clue nor does he care." Then, guess what, I went to another doctor and she was amazing! Got the right meds and got 100% better.
- The food! Most of the time companies give you coupons so you can go get a hot lunch from most restaurants at a discount.
- The infrastructure. Don't like traffic? Neither do the french. The metro is amazing.
- Work life balance. It's actually a law that you're NOT required to answer emails over the weekend. Everyone takes the month of August off (it's a little more nuanced than that, but it's normal).
- People hang out in the park. Didn't know how awesome that would be until I started doing it.
All in all I stayed with my wife in Paris for 1 year. Without her having the right to work it was just too hard to save any money. So we moved back. Given the chance to move back to France, I would in a heartbeat. However, maybe not Paris, maybe more like Montpellier. If anyone has any questions about my experience, feel free to reach out.
My salary in Paris is definitely quite a bit lower than what it was in San Francisco, but I think the lower cost of health care, child care, education and housing largely make up for it. In particular, I feel much less exposed in terms of negative tail events. I'm much less worried about a chronic medical condition or college to wipe me or my future family out financially.
Totally agree about language, healthcare, food, metro, and work-life balance. There are some things money can't buy.
https://www.maddyness.com/2017/06/25/maddyrex-pourquoi-grill...
If you have a good health company sponsored health plan in the US, the kind you get at google or gov't jobs, I think you and your family are probably ok. It's no way to run a country, though. And yeah, there's always that fear that an ambulance will take you somewhere out of network... yeah, you described it pretty accurately as a negative tail event, it would be unlucky but not at all impossible, and it could be ruinous financially[1]
[1] it happens: http://www.sfweekly.com/news/s-f-general-rethinks-high-bills...
> You'll still have to pay Federal taxes if you're a US citizen. I was able to contact H&R block from Paris and sent them ALL my paystubs in order to prove that I had paid French taxes. It didn't matter, I still had to pay in a small some for federal taxes. You'll be double taxed US/FR.
??? The foreign earned income exclusion covers up to $104,000/year once you pass the presence test.
> - The food!
You must be a big fan of ham sandwiches. There isn't a more Parisian food than ham and butter on white bread with nothing else on it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jambon-beurre
If you're a US citizen living and working abroad, you should read:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_earned_income_exclusio...
https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/fore...
And...uhh...this random blog post that I just found in a search on the subject: https://www.remotefinancialplanner.com/foreign-earned-income...
When you file your taxes as a US expat you get to choose between the foreign earned income exclusion and the foreign tax credit. Which you should choose depends on circumstances, but if you're living full time and working in France and earning less than $100k there then clearly you should just exclude your income and then pay nothing to the US.
If understanding taxes in the US is generally complicated, taxes for expats are definitely even more so. Knowing which income you can exclude is important if you plan to live abroad.
> Yes, you can go to a train station and find not-so-good food.
I lived in France for several years (mostly but not exclusively in Paris) and boy howdy is sandwich culture not reduced to anything so far as "you can go to a train station". Nearly every bakery in the country, and there's like one every few blocks in Paris right next to seventeen pharmacies and a fruit stand, has a display case of pre-made sandwiches. Ham and butter on white bread and kebab wraps are major components of the food culture. You even get jambon beurre and kebab flavored potato chips everywhere, though for the money my favorite potato chip flavor was Quick(r) cheeseburger.
Let's not even get into the ubiquity of frozen tv dinners from Picard.
Does France have restaurants? Sure. But so does literally everywhere else.
> It'd be just like going to Subway here
Paris also has a bunch of Subways and McDonalds and Burger Kings and Dominos and whatever other cheap fast food you can think of, and they're all frequently packed with people, because most of the time what people want in France, like everywhere else, is something cheap and fast (hence the sandwiches). They also have a Chipotle at La Defense if you ever get nostalgic, but at lunch time the line goes out the door.
That is quite common if you're an ex-pat. You'll make friends in the ex-pat community long before you make good local friends.
> and you'll ruin everything by being flaky.
Maybe it's an American thing (being flaky), but that doesn't mean others have to accept it. Do you value the friendship? Then stop being flaky.
> If you don't you've broken protocol, this activity shall be logged, and the baker shall and will use it against you later.
Sounds like the Soup Nazi from Seinfeld?