Hacker News Reader

Comment by Andre607 | Hacker News Reader

> these aren’t a surveillance tool if the airlines wanted to have security cameras they would’ve installed them already

The fact that it may be designed as an entertainment system and not as a surveillance system has no bearing on the fact that the former may readily be used for the latter. See Weeping Angel [1] for an example of one such manifested use-case.

[1] https://wikileaks.org/ciav7p1/cms/page_12353643.html

View on HN

What exactly does the capability of an intelligence agency to use a webcam has to do with this? Are you also counting the microphone and camera of every device anyone carries around you in your threat model?

If so there already is zero privacy on any airplane, not to mention in every Starbucks.

I interpreted your reply to be that this camera is intended for entertainment, not surveillance purposes. My response was to point out that entertainment-purposed equipment can and has been repurposed to be surveillance equipment, effectively becoming multipurpose. And that it's therefore not implausible that these cameras could be used for impromptu surveillance such as the example I outlined in my first reply.

By whom? There is no such thing as privacy when traveling via commercial air travel what you are saying is utter nonsense.

Law enforcement and intelligence agencies already have access to your travel itinerary, identification documents, biometric data and surveillance footage from the airport these cameras would add nothing of value.

Please re-read my first comment, as I feel like we are talking past each other. You are talking about generalized surveillance; I presented a specific example of how this particular technology can be used in my first post. The obvious truism that law enforcement agencies have access to a wide array of traveler information has no bearing on the fact that, as I said in my first comment, a bored passenger or flight attendant could use the system to peep on passengers depending on what 'never been activated' means.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com