Sure this is a step in a good direction but there's only so many band-aids you can apply to a gunshot wound. While unscrupulous practices like this bill takes aim at should be weeded out it strikes me as hopeless in light of the bigger picture.
Sure this is a step in a good direction but there's only so many band-aids you can apply to a gunshot wound. While unscrupulous practices like this bill takes aim at should be weeded out it strikes me as hopeless in light of the bigger picture.
In this case the problem is exacerbated by the way that privately insured patients are being exploited to subsidize publicly insured patients;
“A hospital spokesperson initially told Vox that the hospital’s focus is on serving those with public health coverage, even if that means offsetting those costs with high bills for the privately insured.”
It should be illegal to charge two different people different prices for the same procedure at the same hospital. At a more granular level, it should be illegal to price discriminate on anything that can be itemized.
The middle and upper class patients are exploited to pay for publically insured patients who get service below cost which the hospital can’t legally turn away.
I think you're close to a solution with minimal regulatory intervention (Which so far has only made things even more expensive: ACA for example).
I'm curious how this would be reconciled with insurer networks though. A cost savings to insurers IS to have networks and discounts.
2. This sort of cost savings to the insurers is more moving the costs to other people, thus negating most of the cost savings incentives.
But aren't the provider side actors (hospitals, insurance networks, etc) the best placed to figure out how to control costs? It seems like a significant reason therefore for high costs may be because they simply do not feel any significant pressure to reduce them, in part precisely because of abusive behavior like this. If the spigots of inflowing coerced money are tightened, wouldn't that itself be motivation to try to find savings? It is in other industries at least. Same thing with more information and transparency, if providers are required by law to have all the costs laid out upfront and that is all they are ever allowed to collect that itself seems like a reasonable first step towards at the least motivating them to get their own internal systems in order.
That's a charitable way of putting it. It turned the insurers into money movers skimming their profit of the top. It somewhat incentivized them to let costs skyrocket. The more money that changes hands through them the better. A fixed % of a big number is more than a fixed % of a small number. The only thing that stops insurers for covering anything at any price and then just passing the cost and letting premiums really go crazy is that there's still some traces of competition left in the market so people (corporate persons or otherwise) will jump ship to other insurers if premiums get too high.
You can look at the profit limits as incentivizing them to cover more expensive care (which it does do) but it comes at the expense of removing any reason for insurers to seriously care about cost so long as they're somewhat competitive with whoever their competition is. That's a very big tradeoff.
Second, the bill would regulate the prices that the hospital could charge for its care, limiting the fees to 150 percent of the Medicare price or the average contracted rate in the area, whichever is greater.Ultimately I think we're going to need some combination of legislated cost controls and care rationing based on QALYs. Otherwise healthcare will collapse the entire economy. This will all be hugely unpopular.