Isn’t there a way to incinerate such rubbish such that it outputs energy (electricity) and any heavy or toxic materials are scrubbed? May be a bit more expensive but the tech exists.
Waste-to-energy tends to be a relatively win-win way of dealing to trash, but a lot of environmentalists tend to be against it because they feel it takes away from efforts to reduce waste.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dickerson_Generating_Station#M...
Not every bit of trash goes out there. I believe plastic and metal are separated.
http://www.tetrapakrecycling.co.uk/protect-whats-good-enviro...
I doubt it's worth it, though - it's a lot of work for a little low-grade paper waste, and incineration is probably more efficient.