Integrate with a ticketing system, force commits to match a pattern, and you can ensure the rationale is tied to your ticketing system (i.e., commits/merges have to be prefaced with FOO-####)
Ever moved from Github Issues to Jira/Trello or vice-versa? How about Bitbucket to Github (as I did for my current company)? That's a whole lot of context potentially being lost, either in tickets or PR discussions.
How much of that lost context would have ever been used anyway is up for debate, of course. In my experience the answer tends to be "rarely, but sometimes".