In the US you get a bonus of $500/month when your income reaches $128K
twitter.com
twitter.com
Social security is not just for retirement benefits. It's supposed to be a national insurance.
The SS trust fund is used for SS retirement. SSI, while administered by the SSA, comes from the general fund.
Federal payroll taxes also include a separate Medicare tax. Medicare benefits aren't pegged to contributions which is why Medicare is a large and fast growing burden on the general fund, especially considering the apparent political infeasibility of raising tax revenue.
Most states also impose separate disability and unemployment insurance payroll taxes.
Like a company pension or life insurance annuity (and unlike a 401k or IRA), you can't outlive your monthly benefit. The contribution and benefit formulas use actuarial tables so that contributions from beneficiaries who die earlier than expected are used to pay beneficiaries who live longer than expected. (And if you look at actuarial tables from the 1920s and 1930s, they literally nailed life expectancies up to, at least, the 1990s. What they didn't do was bake those actuarial tables into the legislation, instead expecting Congress to periodically adjust age limits.)
Because it's mandatory, you don't end up with a large population of people who chose not to save for retirement living on the streets and otherwise being a burden on society--by their presence if not because of actual welfare payments.
Disability and survivors benefits are a form of income insurance, they're just predicated on the head of the household having actually worked and made minimal contributions.
The income cap and benefit formulas are just progressive enough to bridge the gap between providing minimal benefits and what could be reasonably funded through contributions, considering political realities.
Back then healthcare wasn't much of a concern. Medical science was nascent, care was much more affordable, and expectations were generally very different. Medicare was passed decades later, and of course we're still trying to figure out how healthcare should work.
To reiterate, the specter of socialism meant it was all tied to having actually worked and it was not intended to substantially address wealth inequity. Social security and social justice are not synonymous. You and I may think they mostly overlap, but at least half the country votes otherwise--today and 90 years ago. In any event, we have other programs to address those issues.
It's not a fund; It's an insurance.
An entity that assumes liabilities without maintaining such a conservative fund isn't an insurance company--it's just a business venture (high risk) or a bank (low to moderate risk).
It's not worth nit-picking because Social Security is a hybrid system. Though structured much like a private insurer, it has a significant progressive element (certainly for its time) and is backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. in the sense that it only holds U.S. bonds and also in the sense that the national government is expected to either cover funding gaps or adjust the benefits formula. And there are other programs, like SSI, created later and administered by the same departments. It's a complex picture.
But if the question is why isn't Social Security better--more progressive, funded differently, etc--you have to look at the history.