Without being purely "conservative", i.e. it was first done on phones therefore it should stay on phones, what are the actual arguments for one vs the other? What do phones have that laptops don't, and vice versa?
Without being purely "conservative", i.e. it was first done on phones therefore it should stay on phones, what are the actual arguments for one vs the other? What do phones have that laptops don't, and vice versa?
This solution stores the secret in your home directory, which is easily readable by any process that has access to your hard drive. Anyone with brief access to your laptop/workstation can easily copy the secret. If you back up your home directory, anybody with access to your backups has access to the secret.
Again, forgive my ignorance, but do smartphones routinely include TPM chips that Google Authenticator utilizes? Never heard of that before.
Though it could and probably should. (Really, this 2FA CLI app could probably do so as well, most modern laptops probably have a TPM.)
People are away from their laptops and exposed to risk of then being stolen without immediate knowledge of that fact more often than the same is true of smartphones, which makes laptops somewhat more of a security risk.
Though, I thought that now TOTP in general, on any platform, is at best a second choice after U2F hardware tokens.