They solve the problem of me wanting mortgage bonds, and you wanting insurance on loans. We both want to take opposite positions (me long, you short). Without a synthetic CDO, we are unable to trade - I'll be trying to buy home loans from WaMu and you'll be talking to the AIG sales desk.
Speaking to the gambling point, I believe it was Deutsche bank who went to the government to make sure synthetic CDOs wouldn't be classified as gambling before starting to sell them.
[1] I can't say "issuer" because these were sold around.
Yes.
In my personal opinion the difference between gambling and investment isn't in terminology. It's about expect return. If your expected return is negative than it's gambling, if your expected return is positive it's investment.
You can call it gambling but there's a reason there exist top poker players who win with consistency. If it were really random chance, you wouldn't see players that make a living playing poker.
Think about it this way: if you buy a slot machine to put in your store/bar/etc, are you gambling or investing ? - it's clearly a game of chance, and you might lose money on it, however because the odds are set in your favour in the long term you'll make money. Hence it's an investment rather than gambling.
You do actually get angel investors who invest in poker players with solid track records.
Contrast this with a casino developing super-slots with a $1 million payout. The casino might increase their take, but their is no increase of real wealth in the world.
Liquidity is very valuable. Compare the more and less liquid shares in Chipotle - the only difference between CMG and CMG.B is that CMG.B has more voting rights, but less liquidity.
Or something like that :-).
Check out this post on where to put your money now -- this is not a scam therefore it is not easy, or risk free:
http://scottlocklin.wordpress.com/2010/11/20/investments-for...
What you're saying seems to be a useful distinction, though, but I'd say it's the difference between "risk entertainment" or something else and investment, rather than gambling and investment, because it's all gambling.