Let them crash and burn and serve as an example of the kind of policy you shouldn't enact. There's 50 states and interstate migration is not restricted. At a national level people do very much have the ability to pick one of the 49 other ships if the one they are on is sinking. Sure it would suck for the people who don't see the writing on the wall when their state is going down but I think it would be less damaging in the long term than the status quo.
The point of income taxes is, that we (the society) consider them fair - the high-income-earners don't only pay more taxes in absolute terms, but also in relative terms, because of progressive taxation (personally, I think that tax rates should be based on wealth, not income, and that capital gains should be taxed equally as income, but I'm clearly in the minority with that opinion).
(Personally I think wealth should be taxed somehow too. What's fair? Another conversation. I too think capital gains should be taxed at the same rate or higher than income.)
No, it would reduce federally taxable income by more than 10%, because an income tax will lower income levels in the state. Even after eliminating the deduction for local taxes, the state income tax is lowering federal tax receipts. States can always eat a chunk of the revenue that would otherwise have gone to the federal government, by destroying that revenue.
Are you saying that the economic equilibrium of a higher income tax will be lower pre-tax incomes? That's certainly an interesting theory, though it doesn't comport with any of the empirical data.
Because you can't collect taxes on income that doesn't exist, obviously.
> Are you saying that the economic equilibrium of a higher income tax will be lower pre-tax incomes? That's certainly an interesting theory, though it doesn't comport with any of the empirical data.
Yes, of course that's what I'm saying. This is the same idea as how taxing oil sales will necessarily lower the dollar volume of oil sales. What model are you aware of that doesn't directly imply this?
Is that all the "empirical data" you were thinking of?
And under the new system, it would do exactly the same thing, unless your income is over $100,000/yr, because it's simply designed to adversely effect the political calculus for upper-income taxes, both to reduce political pressure for tax progressivity at the state level and to reduce the viability of high-cost-of-living communities.
Lots of people defending the policy here are acting as if it was a principled rejection of the SALT deduction rather than a calculated strategic limitation on its applicability, and are defending a policy that doesn't exist instead of the actual policy.