There is simply not enough information presented in this article to know whether there is truly a gender bias (in either direction) regarding how Google pays their employees.
There is simply not enough information presented in this article to know whether there is truly a gender bias (in either direction) regarding how Google pays their employees.
E.g.: Google is 70% men. At 100,000 employees: 70,000 Male 30,000 Female
If 5% of men are underpaid that's 3,500 men. If 10% of women are underpaid that's 3,000 women.
More men are underpaid (3,500 > 3,000). But women are twice as likely to be underpaid (10% > 5%).
The article says the opposite with regard to where the salary adjustments went:
> One effect of the adjustments was to create a pronounced imbalance in compensation among lower-level software engineers, one of Google’s largest job groups, with a large number of men identified as being underpaid compared with their female peers. To offset that, further adjustments were made. Google said it saw no pattern in the reasons women were receiving more discretionary pay.
Btw, note that this passage (that I also quoted yesterday for a comment of my own) is now nowhere to be found in the article, that has been heaviy edited since it was posted on HN.
It says no such thing. The "large number" of underpaid men is not being compared against the number of underpaid women.
The article still contains these quotes, which clearly establish that the equity pay raises went disproportionately to men:
> The study, which disproportionately led to pay raises for thousands of men [...]
> In response to the study, Google gave $9.7 million in additional compensation to 10,677 employees for this year. Men account for about 69 percent of the company’s work force, but they received a higher percentage of the money.
This sentence compares the number of men identified as underpaid to the number of women identified as underpaid.
>> The study, which disproportionately led to pay raises for thousands of men
"Disproportionate" is used to signify something that is "out of proportion", in a lay sense, not in the mathematical sense of the ratio between two numbers. It is not a mathematical term that signifies a comparison between percentages, as your comment seems to suggest.
>> they received a higher percentage of the money.
This says nothing about the proportion of men or women who were found to be underpaid. It refers to the percentage of men who received more money. The justification for that is that there are more men in the company.
No, it is saying that the definition of "underpaid" is "making less money than women at the same level."
> This says nothing about the proportion of men or women who were found to be underpaid. It refers to the percentage of men who received more money. The justification for that is that there are more men in the company.
It says that men accounted for 69% of the work force, but received more than 69% of the money that went to equity raises.
1. The average under-compensated man had worked there longer or had been under-compensated longer
AND/OR
2. The average under-compensated man was in a higher paid role.
Hmm...
"Men account for about 69 percent of the company’s work force, but they received a disproportionately higher percentage of the money. "
So, yes, we do have that information.
My understanding is that we're talking about the latter.